That sentence feels almost impossible to imagine now, in an era where the Philadelphia Phillies stand alone as one of baseball’s oldest, most recognizable, and most passionately followed franchises. But before the Phillies became the singular heartbeat of summer in Philadelphia, there was another major-league identity woven deeply into the city’s DNA: the Philadelphia Athletics.
And this week, as the Athletics return to Philadelphia for a series against the Phillies, the city gets a rare opportunity to revisit a baseball life it once knew — and perhaps still misses more than it realizes.
For decades, Philadelphia breathed baseball from both leagues. The Phillies carried the National League flag. The Athletics represented the American League. Two franchises. Two fan bases. Two entirely different baseball identities sharing the same streets, trolley lines, neighborhoods, and conversations.
The Athletics were not some forgotten secondary club. Under the legendary Connie Mack, they became one of the defining organizations in professional sports. Mack managed the team for 50 seasons, often sitting calmly in the dugout wearing a suit and tie while building dynasties that produced stars like Jimmie Foxx, Lefty Grove, Al Simmons, and Mickey Cochrane.
The Athletics won five World Series championships in Philadelphia and, for long stretches, were the more successful and respected franchise in the city.
Imagine walking into Shibe Park in the 1930s.
Vendors yelling through the concourse. Smoke drifting above the grandstand. The massive steel-and-brick ballpark rising over North Philadelphia like a cathedral. One afternoon, the Athletics might be battling the Yankees for the American League pennant. The next day, the Phillies could be hosting a National League rival on the very same field.
That was Philadelphia baseball.
And when the Athletics left for Kansas City after the 1954 season, Philadelphia lost more than a team.
It lost an entire baseball identity.
Today, Philadelphia is unquestionably a Phillies town. Generations have grown up without experiencing the push and pull that naturally comes with two franchises competing for loyalty, relevance, headlines, and history. But this week offers a reminder that Philadelphia once stood at the center of both leagues — a baseball city every bit as important as New York City or Chicago.
And it is impossible not to wonder what could have been had both teams survived here.
Would North Philadelphia still lean Athletics while South Philly rallied around the Phillies? Would summers have revolved around simultaneous pennant races in two leagues? Would divided loyalties have deepened the city’s connection to baseball even further?
The possibilities feel endless because the foundation already existed.
What makes this week feel so unusual is that it briefly reconnects Philadelphia to a version of itself that no longer exists.
Modern sports cities rarely live with divided baseball loyalties anymore. Expansion, relocation, television markets, and economics changed that decades ago. But Philadelphia once belonged to both leagues. For many families, fandom was inherited as deeply as religion or neighborhood allegiance.
Some households grew up Phillies families. Others swore by Connie Mack and the Athletics. Entire sections of the city carried those identities with pride. The comparisons, debates, and rivalries became part of Philadelphia’s sports fabric.
That disappeared when the Athletics left.
And while the Phillies endured and eventually flourished, something about Philadelphia baseball became singular instead of shared.
The Athletics are no longer truly Philadelphia’s team. The franchise’s journey through Kansas City, Oakland, and now its temporary stop in West Sacramento before a planned move to Las Vegas has carried it far from its roots.
But a piece of the franchise still belongs here.
The old photographs still survive. The elephant logo still sparks recognition among historians and older fans. The ghosts of Shibe Park still linger in Philadelphia baseball conversations. The Athletics remain woven into the city’s identity whether Major League Baseball fully embraces that history or not.
That is what makes this series feel bigger than three games in early May.
For a few days, Philadelphia gets to look across the diamond and see a reflection of the baseball life it once lived — a city where two major-league franchises once battled for attention, loyalty, and supremacy in one of America’s greatest baseball towns.
And maybe, just maybe, it serves as a reminder that Philadelphia’s baseball story has always been bigger than one team.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of youth baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »