PHILADELPHIA — The first day of the CACC best-of-three series delivered exactly what a postseason is supposed to bring: momentum swings, late drama, and no shortage of offense.
By the time it was over Friday evening, Chestnut Hill and Jefferson had traded blows — and victories — setting up a decisive Game 3 on Saturday.
Chestnut Hill struck first, riding an early power surge and just enough pitching to hold off a late push in a 10-8 win in Game 1. Jefferson answered emphatically in Game 2, overwhelming the Griffins 13-3 to even the series.
Now, everything funnels into one game.
Game 1 belonged to Chestnut Hill’s ability to build — and protect — a lead.
Wyatt Spinks set the tone immediately with a two-run homer in the first, and the Griffins kept adding pressure throughout the afternoon. Kenyon Motley delivered the biggest swing of the game in the sixth, a three-run double that stretched the lead and created separation.
Michael Pascoe handled the rest — at least for a while.
The right-hander worked seven strong innings, allowing just two runs (one earned) while scattering six hits to earn the win. But what looked comfortable turned tense late.
Jefferson erupted for six runs over the final two innings, highlighted by Andrew Holub’s three-run homer in the eighth and Ryan Mallen’s blast in the ninth. The Rams brought the tying run to the plate before Brady Gusttitus closed the door.
Chestnut Hill survived — barely.
Jefferson made sure there would be no such suspense in Game 2.
From the outset, the Rams flipped the tone of the series. They scored three times in the first inning, added another in the second, and never allowed Chestnut Hill to settle in.
Luis Beato Mora homered. Julio Frometa Gomez homered and drove in three. Holub continued his strong day with two hits and two RBIs. By the sixth inning, the game had broken open.
A five-run sixth — fueled by timely hits, aggressive baserunning, and defensive miscues — turned a manageable deficit into a rout.
On the mound, Patrick Karbach gave Jefferson exactly what it needed: stability. The right-hander went seven innings, allowing three runs (two earned) while limiting Chestnut Hill to just three hits and keeping the game under control from the middle innings on.
The contrast between the two games was stark.
In the opener, Chestnut Hill capitalized on mistakes and built innings. In the nightcap, Jefferson did the same — only more efficiently, and with far more consistency.
And now, the margin for error is gone.
Chestnut Hill (23-21) and Jefferson (23-20) head into Saturday with the series tied, the adjustments made, and the stakes fully understood.
One game. One winner.
That’s how this was always going to be decided.
Recent Philly | Phillies Baseball News | Philadelphia Baseball Review
- CACC Tournament: Jefferson responds, forces winner-take-all after Chestnut Hill takes opener (May 1)
- Ursinus lets five-run lead slip as Johns Hopkins rallies late in Centennial tournament (May 1)
- Chase Shugart earns two wins as Phillies sweep doubleheader with pair of walk-offs (April 30)
- Stott, Crawford deliver late as Phillies overcome missed chances in win over Giants (April 30)
- Rob Thomson didn’t duck it — a classy, accountable exit in Philadelphia (April 30)
- How to navigate the Fishtown Card Show: Insider tips from Wheelhouse’s Matt Stratton (April 30)
- Ursinus rides four-run third, advances in Centennial Conference tournament with 4-2 win (April 29)
- Penn State Brandywine rallies past early mistakes, earns first United East Tournament win (April 29)
- Valley Forge rallies late to survive United East play-in test, advances with 12-8 win (April 29)
- Luzardo dominates as Phillies back Don Mattingly’s “better baseball” message in 7-0 win (April 28)
- Rob Thomson was the move — but not the problem for the Phillies (April 28)
- Phillies fire Rob Thomson after 9–19 start, name Don Mattingly interim manager (April 28)
- Pagano and Shurtleff earn Player of the Week honors from the Philadelphia Baseball Review (April 27)
- Saint Joseph’s routs La Salle, sets program record with 19th Atlantic 10 win (April 27)
- Eastern wins finale, but postseason hopes fall short despite record-setting 26-win season (April 27)
- Ursinus clinches Centennial postseason berth, earns No. 4 seed after split with nationally ranked Johns Hopkins (April 27)
- Phillies fall to Braves 6-2 as Aaron Nola’s struggles continue, drop to 9-19 (April 27)
- Phillies snap 10-game losing streak behind Bryce Harper, Zack Wheeler in extra-inning win (April 26)
- Phillies lose tenth straight as familiar mistakes continue in Atlanta (April 25)
- Saint Joseph’s Gaines earns national recognition as postseason races tighten across region (April 24)
- Phillies show fight but can’t finish as losing streak reaches nine (April 24)
- Phillies release Taijuan Walker, but at 8-16, the questions aren’t going away (April 23)
- Phillies spiral continues as Taijuan Walker’s struggles force a looming decision (April 23)
- Saint Joseph’s claims Liberty Bell Classic title behind Beggy, Sweeney at Citizens Bank Park (April 22)
- Phillies’ spiral deepens in 7-4 loss at Wrigley: Walks, missed moments, and a season slipping (April 22)
- Swingman Classic comes to Philadelphia: MLB’s All-Star stage expands its future (April 21)
- Phillies fall to 8–15 as Nola struggles, offense goes hitless again with RISP in loss to Cubs (April 20)
- Shurtleff dominates, Gale explodes as weekly honors spotlight Penn, Saint Joseph’s (April 20)
- Swarthmore stuns No. 4 Johns Hopkins, throws Centennial race into chaos (April 20)
- Saint Joseph’s takes control, West Chester responds, and the postseason picture tightens across Philly college baseball (April 20)
- Phillies News from the Philadelphia Baseball Review
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of youth baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »
