Alvarado had started walking toward the dugout in the seventh inning. So had several of his teammates. Marcus Semien had swung through a 2-2 pitch, and for a moment, it looked as if the Phillies had escaped the inning still trailing by just one run.
Only they had not escaped anything.
Home-plate umpire Brian Walsh ruled that J.T. Realmuto had not caught the foul tip cleanly. The ball had hit the dirt. Semien was still alive. The Phillies were sent back to their positions. Alvarado climbed back on the mound. Then, before the biggest pitch of the night, he stood there with his arms out.
He needed a baseball.
When he finally got one, Semien made sure the inning did not stay weird. He made it decisive.
The Mets second baseman drove Alvarado’s next pitch to the angled wall in left-center for a two-run triple, pushing New York’s lead to three and sending the Phillies toward a 6-4 loss at Citizens Bank Park in their first meeting of the season with their division rival.
For Alvarado, it was not just one strange sequence. It was another damaging inning in a season that has become increasingly difficult to explain away. He now owns a 6.58 ERA over 26 innings. Over his last seven appearances, that number has climbed to 9.45.
The most revealing explanation came from Alvarado himself.
“They feel confident that they can hit against me right now,” Alvarado said via a club interpreter. “It seems like 100 miles an hour is something they see a lot at this level. It’s not surprising anymore.”
That is the concern for the Phillies. Alvarado said he feels better mentally. He believes he is throwing more strikes than he has in past years. But when a pitcher built on violence and discomfort admits hitters are no longer surprised by the velocity, the issue becomes bigger than one bad pitch or one strange call.
For years, Alvarado’s margin for error was intimidation. The fastball got on hitters. The cutter and sinker came with force. Even when the command wandered, the stuff gave him room to survive. Now he is throwing more strikes, but too many are being met with conviction.
Asked what it was like to think the inning was over and then have to reset, Alvarado said the moment did not affect him.
“Nothing, actually,” Alvarado said. “I feel great. In spots like that, I’m always optimistic. I try to remain optimistic, control my mind, stay calm with my body language. So I feel good.”
The Phillies need the results to start matching that feeling.
The seventh began with Carson Benge singling, stealing second and moving to third on a wild pitch. Alvarado nearly worked through the trouble, but with two outs, Eric Wagaman shot a go-ahead single to right to give the Mets a 4-3 lead. Mark Vientos walked. Then came Semien, the foul tip, the brief confusion and the triple that broke the inning open.
Interim manager Don Mattingly said afterward the umpire crew got the call right. That did not make the sequence any less damaging.
The Phillies had spent the previous six innings trying to make sure the game did not get there.
Soto started the scoring in the first inning, driving a two-out solo homer off Aaron Nola to right field. A.J. Ewing followed later in the inning with an RBI double that scored Jared Young, giving the Mets a 2-0 lead before the Phillies had settled into the night.
The Phillies answered in the bottom half, though even that rally came with a cost.
Trea Turner was hit by a pitch to open the inning, stayed in long enough to score on Alec Bohm’s RBI single, then exited two innings later with what the club announced as a right calf contusion.
It was the second time in four days Turner had been forced from a game after being hit by a pitch. On Monday against the Marlins, he took one off the right wrist and left early. He missed Tuesday, returned Wednesday and looked like he had found something again, going 3-for-5 with a double and a stolen base.
Then came Thursday.
Mattingly said the pitch caught Turner near the Achilles area and that Turner was having trouble putting pressure on the leg. He did not indicate that the Phillies expected a long absence, but the image was enough to matter. For a lineup still searching for rhythm, even a short interruption for Turner carries weight.
The injury forced the Phillies to reshuffle. Edmundo Sosa moved to shortstop. Justin Crawford entered the game. Derek Hill shifted to right. Brandon Marsh moved to left. The Phillies adjusted and kept pushing.
Sosa led off the second with a triple, but the Phillies stranded him. Soto made that hurt even more in the third, lifting another homer off Nola to right-center to make it 3-1. Nola did not think it was gone. He said he did not think Soto did, either.
“No, I didn’t,” Nola said when asked if he thought Soto’s second homer would leave the park. “I don’t think he did either. I think the wind just blew it. The wind was kind of circling out there.”
The Phillies kept answering. Bohm doubled home Kyle Schwarber in the third to trim the deficit to one. In the fourth, Bryson Stott singled, stole second and scored when Hill lined a single to center. Ewing’s throwing error allowed Hill to take second, and the game was tied, 3-3.
That was the kind of night Nola gave them. Not dominant. Not clean. But survivable.
In his 300th career start with the Phillies, Nola allowed three runs, two earned, on seven hits. He walked one and struck out six. He gave up the two solo homers to Soto, but he also gave the Phillies a game they had every chance to win.
That milestone put Nola in rare franchise company. Only Steve Carlton, Robin Roberts and Chris Short had started 300 games for the Phillies before him.
Nola said he did not know until Thursday.
“I didn’t realize that until today,” Nola said. “I’m very grateful to be able to start that many games, especially for one organization, and to be healthy for all those. Definitely grateful for it.”
It was the right sentiment for a milestone that says something about durability, trust and organizational permanence. Nola has been here long enough to become part of the Phillies’ pitching record book. He has taken the ball often enough to stand with names that define eras of the franchise.
But baseball rarely pauses for sentiment, especially on nights when Soto is driving balls into the seats and the bullpen is trying to find itself in real time.
Nola’s milestone became background. Turner’s injury became another worry. Alvarado’s seventh became the difference.
The Phillies tried to make one last push in the ninth. Realmuto scored on Crawford’s RBI single, cutting the Mets’ lead to 6-4 and bringing the tying run to the plate. Schwarber got one final swing and lined a ball sharply to right, but Brett Baty made the catch to end the game.
That was how the night closed: with the Phillies close enough to make the loss sting more.
They answered Soto twice. They had Nola keep them in the game on a night that mattered personally, even if he would never frame it that way. But they also lost Turner, stranded Sosa after a leadoff triple and watched Alvarado’s command and confidence remain out of sync with his results.
The Phillies did not get blown out Thursday.
They got reminded how thin the difference can be between a strange win and a strange loss.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of youth baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »