PHILADELPHIA -- Harrison Bader’s Philly cameo always felt like a February question mark disguised as an October answer.
He showed up at the deadline, gave the Phillies a real center fielder, and — for about six weeks — looked like the rare rental who actually changes the temperature of a lineup. He hit .305/.361/.463 with five homers, 11 doubles, and a triple in his 50 games down the stretch in Philadelphia.
And now he’s gone, because the San Francisco Giants just paid for that version of Bader: two years, $20.5 million (with incentives that can push it to $21 million).
So here’s the actual question the Phillies had to answer — and it’s not “Did we like Harrison Bader?”
It’s: Did they like him at $10 million a year, for his age-31 season and beyond, while also trying to get younger in the outfield and carve out a runway for Justin Crawford?
Because that’s what that deal is: about $10.25 million per season for a player whose loudest tool is still the one you can’t measure with a bat sensor — range. Bader did hit .277 with 17 homers last season split between Minnesota and Philadelphia, which is the kind of stat line that gets an agent’s phone to ring. But even in the best version of the argument, you’re paying for defense, energy, and competence in center — with the usual footnote about durability (and we all saw that groin injury arrive at the worst time).
Now slide Adolis García into the frame, and the comparison gets interesting — because the Phillies already spent roughly that same annual money on a different kind of gamble.
García is in on a one-year, $10 million deal. That’s not a commitment — it’s a bet you can unwind. And it solves a different problem.
The Phillies didn’t just need “another outfielder.” They needed a right fielder who can catch the baseball without turning every deep fly into an apology tour. García gives them that: +1 outs above average in right field in 2025, and one of the stronger outfield arms in the sport (91.9 mph arm strength, per Statcast).
Does he come with warts? Sure. He hit .227 with 19 homers, 75 RBIs and a .665 OPS last season. There is no doubt, he's a rebound play after two straight down years.
But that’s also the point: the Phillies bought upside without buying years.
With Bader, you’re buying a player who — even at his peak value — would have been competing with your own future plan in Crawford.
So should the Phillies have retained Bader at that price?
If your goal is to build the safest possible April roster, you can make the case. A proven big-league center fielder at ~$10 million a year is not outrageous in this market — especially one who just gave you meaningful at-bats in a pennant race.
But if your goal is to walk into 2026 with a clearer outfield identity — younger in center, stronger defense in right, and flexible money — then the Phillies made the colder, cleaner call.
What looks better entering 2026?
On pure fit, García looks like the better move: one year, right-handed pop potential, and a defensive upgrade where the Phillies have been bleeding runs and patience. Bader looks like the better story — because he felt like October — but his new contract looks like the kind of deal teams sign when they need center field answers now, not when they’re trying to grow one.
And the Phillies, for once, are telling you they want to grow one.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of youth baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »