If you want to understand how players feel about where this is heading, rewind to last summer inside the Phillies clubhouse. Rob Manfred was meeting with the team and explaining the league’s financial concerns, talking about spending gaps and what he called cost certainty. He never said the words salary cap, but players felt the implication immediately. That is when Bryce Harper stood up, interrupted the discussion, and told the commissioner that if he planned to raise the subject of a cap he could leave the room. According to those present the room went silent. It was not a performance or a headline grab. It was one of the game’s most prominent players expressing openly what many others had only voiced privately.
Recent reporting has confirmed that several owners intend to push for some form of a cap or a cap-like mechanism in the next CBA. The MLB Players Association responded quickly and firmly, calling the idea an absolute line it will not cross and framing the push as a declaration of war. MLB and the union also held preliminary labor discussions late in the offseason. These were not formal negotiations, but the fact that both sides met this early signals that each is preparing for a difficult year.
The salary-cap debate is only one pressure point. Another is the instability in baseball’s local television market. Nine clubs, including the Cardinals, Braves, Reds, Tigers, Royals, Angels, Marlins, Brewers and Rays, severed their deals with FanDuel Sports Network after its parent company missed a rights-fee payment. MLB has already prepared contingency plans to produce and distribute those games if necessary. Manfred has said publicly that local media revenue represents more than 20 percent of league-wide income. When a revenue stream that large becomes uncertain, front offices change their behavior.
The effects are already showing. Large-market teams that normally drive the pace of the offseason have acted more deliberately. Others are choosing shorter contracts or structures that limit exposure in 2027, the first year under a new agreement. No club will admit this directly, but front offices are clearly preparing for multiple scenarios including the possibility that the financial system that governs payroll and roster construction may be significantly altered.
Arbitration has reflected the same tension. Tarik Skubal’s record filing of $32 million was not viewed only through the lens of individual performance. It was interpreted as a benchmark in a shifting market, because both sides recognize that any precedent set this year could influence negotiations under a modified system. Every number matters more than usual because the ground beneath the system may be moving.
What is at stake goes far beyond salaries. The CBA determines arbitration rules, revenue-sharing formulas, service-time calculations, competitive-balance policies, the structure of the international amateur market, and even the size and shape of the postseason. Any change in these areas could influence competitive balance, player development pipelines, roster construction strategies, and the earning timeline for an entire generation of players.
Players see the coming negotiation as existential. Harper’s confrontation with Manfred was not an isolated flare-up, but a reflection of broader concerns around the league. The MLBPA remembers the 2021 to 2022 lockout that lasted 99 days, froze transactions and delayed the start of the season. Many players believe the stakes are even higher now.
Owners believe a new framework is needed to create more predictable spending, stabilize revenues in small markets, and close competitive gaps. Players believe those same proposals threaten hard-won freedoms and earning power. That is why the stakes are so high. This is not a disagreement over minor rule tweaks. It is the framework of the sport itself.
Fans will notice decisions this season that go beyond traditional roster logic. They reflect a league operating under a countdown clock. Baseball is not at the brink yet, but the shadow of December is impossible to ignore. This will not be remembered simply as the final year of the current agreement. It will be remembered as the year the entire sport held its breath while the future of its financial and competitive system waited on deck.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of youth baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »