PHILADELPHIA -- The Phillies’ interest in Bo Bichette has become January’s most compelling storyline, not because it guarantees movement, but because it forces a sharper baseball question: if the club somehow lands the 27-year-old All-Star, where exactly would he fit in a lineup already anchored by stars?
That is the part of the conversation that has hovered beneath the surface. Bichette is not a luxury add or an end-of-the-line depth piece. He is a .311 hitter who finished tied for second in Major League Baseball in batting average last season, behind only Aaron Judge’s .331. He collected 181 hits, second-most in the sport, and did it with a mix of line-drive contact, gap power, and an approach that rarely wastes an at-bat. When a player like that joins a contending lineup, the very shape of the offense begins to shift.
The most logical answer, and the one that creates the most trouble for opposing pitchers, is writing Bichette’s name in the two-hole. Trea Turner won the National League batting title with a .304 average and led the league in hits with 179 while stealing 36 bases. Pair those skills with Bichette’s ability to attack fastballs early in counts and drive the ball to all fields, and suddenly the first inning of every game becomes a gauntlet instead of a warmup. If Turner reaches, there is no breather. If Bichette reaches, there is immediate stress. And if both reach, Bryce Harper steps into the box with a pitcher already working from the stretch.
For a team that finished tied for second in MLB in batting average at .258 and eighth in runs per game at 4.78, that matters. The Phillies have been good, but the offense has often leaned on Schwarber’s power and Harper’s plate discipline. When both go quiet at the same time, which happened again in their NLDS exit, the lineup can flatten out. Bichette gives them a right-handed bat with a high floor, a hitter who forces pitchers into the strike zone and increases the pitch count without sacrificing contact.
There is another version of the lineup that places Bichette in the three-spot behind Turner and Harper. That arrangement serves a different purpose. Harper has been pitched around in big moments for three straight seasons, particularly late in games and especially by right-handed pitchers. Putting Bichette behind him erases some of that comfort. If Harper works a 2–0 count, opponents cannot simply nibble at the edges. A walk means a free baserunner delivered to a .300 hitter who handles velocity and covers the plate. That changes late-game decision making.
Even the more conservative alignment that places Bichette fifth reshapes the inning-to-inning rhythm of the offense. It turns the bottom third of the lineup into another top third and removes the soft landing that opponents relied on. It also forces opposing managers to rethink bullpen sequencing. If you use your best left-hander early to deal with Schwarber and Harper, you leave Bichette sitting on a right-handed reliever. If you save that left-hander for later, you risk Schwarber deciding the game with one swing. Bichette complicates everything, which is exactly what a lineup-deepening hitter is supposed to do.
Wherever he hits, Bichette adds balance. The Phillies have not had a right-handed contact hitter with this kind of impact in the first four spots since Jayson Werth. Turner can set the table. Harper and Schwarber bring elite power. Bryson Stott and Alec Bohm offer steady contact. Bichette is something different, a bat that stabilizes the nightly pulse of the offense. He reduces volatility. He extends innings. He forces pitchers into disadvantageous counts.
His defensive placement is a separate conversation that hinges on Bohm, Stott, and long-term roster choices. But strictly from an offensive perspective, Bichette fits cleanly into the top three spots of the lineup and raises the team’s ceiling. Whether the Phillies pursue him aggressively or simply perform due diligence remains to be seen. If they were to bring Bichette to Philadelphia, the lineup card becomes something else entirely: deeper, more balanced, and far more difficult for opponents to navigate.
And that, on its own, explains why the meeting is worth having.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of youth baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »