PHILADELPHIA -- If you were waiting for the moment this Phillies offseason stopped being theoretical and turned into something louder, Thursday might be it.
League sources confirmed a report in The Athletic that the Phillies have scheduled a virtual meeting “in the coming days” with free-agent infielder Bo Bichette, with Matt Gelb and Ken Rosenthal reporting that the club’s interest is “legitimate” and that a deal would likely force the Phillies to move on from long-time roster pillars J.T. Realmuto and Alec Bohm. For a front office that has spent most of the winter talking about flexibility, this is where the word stops being a concept and starts looking like an ultimatum.
The framework isn’t hard to see. Realmuto is still on the open market, and the Phillies have said publicly and privately that they’d like to bring him back. But he’s entering his age-35 season, and his 2025 line — .257/.315/.384 with a .699 OPS — was his lowest offensive output in Philadelphia. That doesn’t erase what he still brings with game-planning, leadership and a trust level with pitchers that’s been built over six years. It does make it fair to ask how far you go, in dollars and in years, for a catcher whose prime almost by definition lives behind him. Bohm, meanwhile, checked one box Thursday when he and the Phillies avoided arbitration at $10.2 million for 2026. That number said “middle-of-the-order corner infielder in his walk-up arbitration years.” It did not say “untouchable.” Avoiding a hearing never eliminates the possibility of a trade; if anything, it gives potential suitors a clean salary figure to plug into their own spreadsheets.
Even before Thursday, people around the game were reading the tea leaves. Last weekend, Jon Heyman of The New York Post reported that the Phillies were among the clubs in on Bichette and noted two details that matter a lot more today than they did then: that Bichette has a strong relationship with new Phillies bench coach Don Mattingly from their time together in Toronto, and that Phillies players were texting Bichette about the idea of joining them while he was in the middle of his own wedding celebration. That’s the kind of stuff you file away in December. When The Athletic comes back a few days later and says there’s a video call on the books and the interest is “legitimate,” it stops feeling like background noise and starts sounding like the soundtrack to a pivot.
The baseball reasons are as straightforward as they are expensive. Bichette turns 28 in March and is the kind of free agent who almost never hits the market — a middle-of-the-diamond bat, a two-time All-Star, and a player who, for three straight years, has lived on the short list of “guys you don’t let beat you in October.” He led the American League in hits in both 2021 (191) and 2022 (189), then hit .311 with 18 homers and 94 RBIs in 2025 for a Blue Jays team that pushed the Dodgers to Game 7 of the World Series. He did all of that while playing through a left knee sprain that cost him most of September and forced him off shortstop to second base during Toronto’s postseason run. Evaluators who watched that series still talk about how compromised he looked physically — and how much damage he did anyway.
What makes this complicated for the Phillies isn’t whether Bichette makes them better. Drop that bat into a lineup that already has Bryce Harper, Trea Turner, Kyle Schwarber and the rest of the usual suspects and you either found your cleanup hitter or you’ve pushed someone with a “3” or “4” next to his name into an even more terrifying spot. What makes it complicated is everything that has to move around him. Public metrics have been unkind to Bichette’s defense at shortstop; he’s deep in the red in both Defensive Runs Saved and outs above average over his big-league time.
The flip side is that, according to multiple reports, he’s told interested teams he’s willing to move off shortstop, and we’ve already seen him handle second base on the game’s biggest stage. The Phillies would love him at third. If he lands at second instead, the corresponding move is almost obvious: Bohm gets moved in a trade, Bichette takes over at second, and Bryson Stott — who has already bounced from shortstop to second once — shifts across the diamond to third until top prospect Aidan Miller forces his way into the picture.
That’s where the human side of a transaction collides with the math. Bohm has gone from first-round pick to fallen prospect to everyday third baseman in Philadelphia, and this past season he finally looked like the guy the organization always thought he could be. Realmuto has been one of the pillars of the entire Harper era, the guy whose name shows up in almost every conversation about why the Phillies’ clubhouse works as well as it does. Moving on from one of them would be jarring. Moving on from both in the same winter, in service of a single player, is the kind of thing you only do if you believe that player fundamentally changes your championship odds.
And then there’s the bill. People in the industry entered the offseason talking about Bichette as a $200-million-plus player. Some national projections have him in the seven-year, $200-to-$210 million neighborhood, which puts him in the high-20s to $30 million-a-year range. Bohm’s $10.2 million is already on the books. Realmuto, if he returns, probably lives in the low-to-mid-teens on an AAV. If the Phillies have roughly $25 million mentally earmarked for the Bohm/Realmuto combination and Bichette walks in asking for something closer to $30 million a year, someone in the room has to raise their hand and say, “That extra five isn’t really five — once you factor in the top competitive-balance-tax tier and a 110 percent tax rate, it’s more than double.” That’s what it looks like when you’re already brushing up against the final luxury-tax line. The question for John Middleton & Co. is whether the upgrade from Bohm-plus-Realmuto to Bichette-plus-“Catcher To Be Named Later” is big enough to justify that kind of surcharge.
None of this is happening in a vacuum. Alex Bregman and Eugenio Suárez are still on the free-agent market, and a handful of teams that need help at third base or in the middle infield have been doing the same mental math the Phillies are doing now. If those bats come off the board and Bohm is still in red pinstripes, there will be clubs, some of them with more payroll room than Philadelphia, willing to talk themselves into a 29-year-old with a solid offensive floor and two years of control left. The Phillies don’t have to move him. They may have to decide whether holding him makes more sense than using him as one of the pieces that pay for the Bichette era.
That’s what makes Thursday feel less like a rumor and more like a fork in the road. The Phillies have spent most of this winter living in the space between paths: talking to Realmuto’s camp, monitoring a third-base market that hasn’t quite moved, keeping tabs on an infield class headlined by Bichette and Bregman without ever quite stepping out onto the dance floor.
That’s where the human side of a transaction collides with the math. Bohm has gone from first-round pick to fallen prospect to everyday third baseman in Philadelphia, and this past season he finally looked like the guy the organization always thought he could be. Realmuto has been one of the pillars of the entire Harper era, the guy whose name shows up in almost every conversation about why the Phillies’ clubhouse works as well as it does. Moving on from one of them would be jarring. Moving on from both in the same winter, in service of a single player, is the kind of thing you only do if you believe that player fundamentally changes your championship odds.
And then there’s the bill. People in the industry entered the offseason talking about Bichette as a $200-million-plus player. Some national projections have him in the seven-year, $200-to-$210 million neighborhood, which puts him in the high-20s to $30 million-a-year range. Bohm’s $10.2 million is already on the books. Realmuto, if he returns, probably lives in the low-to-mid-teens on an AAV. If the Phillies have roughly $25 million mentally earmarked for the Bohm/Realmuto combination and Bichette walks in asking for something closer to $30 million a year, someone in the room has to raise their hand and say, “That extra five isn’t really five — once you factor in the top competitive-balance-tax tier and a 110 percent tax rate, it’s more than double.” That’s what it looks like when you’re already brushing up against the final luxury-tax line. The question for John Middleton & Co. is whether the upgrade from Bohm-plus-Realmuto to Bichette-plus-“Catcher To Be Named Later” is big enough to justify that kind of surcharge.
None of this is happening in a vacuum. Alex Bregman and Eugenio Suárez are still on the free-agent market, and a handful of teams that need help at third base or in the middle infield have been doing the same mental math the Phillies are doing now. If those bats come off the board and Bohm is still in red pinstripes, there will be clubs, some of them with more payroll room than Philadelphia, willing to talk themselves into a 29-year-old with a solid offensive floor and two years of control left. The Phillies don’t have to move him. They may have to decide whether holding him makes more sense than using him as one of the pieces that pay for the Bichette era.
That’s what makes Thursday feel less like a rumor and more like a fork in the road. The Phillies have spent most of this winter living in the space between paths: talking to Realmuto’s camp, monitoring a third-base market that hasn’t quite moved, keeping tabs on an infield class headlined by Bichette and Bregman without ever quite stepping out onto the dance floor.
Now there’s a meeting on the calendar, a report in The Athletic that says the interest is real, a Heyman note about Mattingly and wedding-week texts, and an arbitration settlement that leaves Bohm’s salary neatly defined.
Maybe nothing comes of it. Maybe Bichette ends up back in Toronto, or in the Bronx, or as the solution to someone else’s infield puzzle. But for the first time this winter, the idea of him in red pinstripes feels less like a message-board fantasy and more like an honest-to-goodness possibility, one that, if it happens, will reshape the Phillies’ roster and payroll in ways that would have been unthinkable not all that long ago.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of youth baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »