The question used to arrive sometime around February.
Are you playing baseball this spring?
Now, in many corners of youth baseball, there is barely time to ask it. Spring becomes summer. Summer becomes August tournaments. August becomes fall ball. Fall ball runs toward Thanksgiving. Indoor workouts begin a few weeks later.
And suddenly a 10-year-old doesn't have a baseball season.
He has a baseball year.
Across Philadelphia and the surrounding region, fall baseball has proliferated at nearly every level of the youth game. Neighborhood programs offer it. Travel organizations offer it. Tournament operators certainly offer it. For families already accustomed to spending spring and summer weekends at ballfields, continuing into September and October can almost feel like the natural next step.
But perhaps youth baseball is asking the wrong question.
Instead of where is your kid playing this fall?, maybe it should be:
Does your kid need to play fall baseball at all?
Especially if that kid is 9, 10, 11 or 12.
“I’ve seen kids go away from summer, spend fall playing and look like a radically different player come spring, but that’s usually right around high school age,” said a Philadelphia Public League head coach who requested anonymity.
That distinction matters.
There is a developmental argument for fall baseball, particularly as players approach high school. A 14-year-old can use September and October to adjust to a bigger field, learn another position, rebuild a swing or accumulate repetitions before competing for a high school roster.
There are younger players who can benefit, too. A 12-year-old who spent the spring buried on the bench may need at-bats. A 10-year-old learning to catch may benefit from additional innings. A player relatively new to baseball may simply need opportunities to play.
But need is different from availability.
And somewhere in the expansion of the youth baseball economy, the existence of another season has begun to create the impression that serious players are supposed to participate in it.
For Gregory Swindell, a coach based in the Fox Chase neighborhood in Philadelphia, the calculation should begin with what happened before September — particularly for pitchers.
“Yeah, you got to figure some of these kids already have 70, 80, maybe even more innings on their arms, depending on how many teams they played for in the spring,” Swindell said. “You really got to think about long-term — does this make sense?”
Major League Baseball and USA Baseball's Pitch Smart recommendations provide some perspective. Pitchers ages 9 through 12 are advised not to exceed 80 combined innings in a 12-month period and to take at least four months away from throwing annually, including at least two to three consecutive months. The guidelines also emphasize athleticism, physical fitness and fun at those ages.
So consider the modern 11-year-old.
He begins indoor workouts in January. His neighborhood season opens in April. Maybe he also pitches for a travel team. The schedules overlap. Memorial Day brings a tournament. Then comes summer baseball, another tournament team or perhaps guest appearances for another organization.
By August, the relevant number isn't how many innings he threw for one team.
It's how many he threw for all of them.
Then fall registration opens.
The question shouldn't be whether his arm is capable of throwing another inning.
The question should be what another 20 innings are supposed to accomplish.
“Fall ball can be used as a tool for players to get more reps, to gain more experience, and to work on their game a bit,” said Bensalem-based coach Peter Hampton. “It really shouldn’t be as competitive as what you do in the spring and summer.”
That's probably the best argument for fall baseball — and also the clearest definition of what it should be.
A tool. Not another championship season.
Put the shortstop in center field. Let the backup catcher catch. Give the seventh hitter more at-bats. Teach instead of managing every inning as though a plastic trophy is hanging in the balance.
Fall should provide room for failure.
Too often, youth baseball simply takes everything from the spring and summer — standings, travel, tournament brackets, pitching demands, weekend doubleheaders — and moves it onto a cooler calendar.
Then everyone wonders why kids never stop.
The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that young athletes receive two to three months away from each particular sport during the year and notes that year-round participation and repeated high-volume events such as weekend tournaments can contribute to accumulated physical stress. It also encourages opportunities for free play during those breaks.
That makes the under-12 question particularly important.
Is an additional competitive baseball season really necessary for a 9-year-old?
In most cases, probably not.
That doesn't mean a child who loves baseball should be forbidden from picking up a glove after Labor Day. Nor does it mean every fall league is harmful. A once- or twice-a-week developmental program with reasonable workloads is considerably different from another travel schedule built around tournaments and winning.
But there is no developmental emergency requiring every serious 10- or 11-year-old baseball player to spend September and October chasing another 25 games.
At those ages, becoming a better athlete may be every bit as valuable as becoming a more polished baseball player.
Play soccer.
Play basketball.
Throw a football.
Run.
Jump.
Change direction.
Learn how to use the rest of the body.
The AAP advises caution with early specialization and year-round training, noting concerns about overuse injuries, mental stress and burnout while emphasizing that participating in different activities can help children develop a broader range of motor skills.
The Public League coach sees the same tension from the baseball side.
“Honestly, I think there are a group of kids that do need the extra work and progressions, but we’ve become so hooked on tournaments and drip and everything else that we forget about the fact some of these kids are playing baseball nearly 10 months out of the year — if not more,” he said.
“On paper, you think that’s awesome. In reality, it isn’t. It isn’t good for the bodies, and it isn’t good for their growth as an athlete.”
That may be the most important line in the entire fall-ball conversation.
Growth as an athlete.
There is a growing assumption within youth baseball that more baseball produces better baseball players.
More teams. More instructors. More tournaments. More games. More swings. More innings.
The research surrounding pitching workloads should at least make adults skeptical of that equation. Studies have consistently identified workload — including more innings, more pitches and more months of pitching per year — as an important risk factor for arm problems among young pitchers.
There is also an important age distinction.
At 13 and 14, baseball begins changing. Players move toward the high-school game. Competition for roster spots increases. Physical development accelerates. Skills that may have been sufficient at 11 suddenly need refinement.
Fall baseball can have legitimate value there.
That is precisely where the Public League coach said he has seen players make noticeable jumps between summer and spring.
Even then, however, more does not mean unlimited. Pitch Smart recommends that 13- and 14-year-old pitchers remain under 100 innings during a 12-month period, take four months away from throwing each year and avoid playing for multiple teams simultaneously.
So perhaps fall baseball shouldn't have one answer for everybody.
For an 8-year-old, fall might mean putting the glove away and playing soccer.
For a 10-year-old who just finished 60 games, the next developmental step might be basketball rather than another baseball tournament.
For a 12-year-old who barely played in the spring, a low-pressure fall league could be exactly what he needs.
For a 14-year-old trying to prepare for his first high school season, structured fall development might make an enormous difference.
And for a pitcher of any of those ages who has spent six months bouncing between school, neighborhood and travel teams?
The smartest fall program might be no fall program at all.
That is not falling behind.
That is development, too.
Youth baseball has become exceptionally good at creating another opportunity to play. There is almost always another team, another tournament, another lesson or another season available for families willing to find it and pay for it.
The harder skill may now be knowing when to say no.
Because childhood isn't a race to accumulate the most baseball before high school.
And sometimes the best thing you can do for a young baseball player in October is let him stop being a baseball player for a while.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
