The Phillies have 37 games remaining, a postseason spot to protect and a season that somehow came back to life after appearing nearly dead before May arrived.
And now their manager may be a lame duck.
Because apparently the Phillies needed another complication.
USA Today’s Bob Nightengale reported Sunday that Alex Cora is expected to become the Phillies’ next manager unless interim manager Don Mattingly leads Philadelphia to at least the World Series. Cora already turned down the job once, after Dave Dombrowski approached him following his dismissal by Boston in April.
The Cora connection is not new.
The timing is what makes this weird.
The Phillies are 67-58. They just swept Minnesota. They have climbed all the way back from a 9-19 start and are fighting for one of the National League’s Wild Card spots. Mattingly has gone 58-39 since replacing Rob Thomson.
That is a .598 winning percentage.
And with six weeks left in the regular season, the conversation surrounding the man who helped save the season has suddenly shifted from whether he can take the Phillies into October to whether somebody else already has his job in 2027.
That is one strange way to enter a pennant race.
Nightengale’s report effectively establishes an almost impossible standard for Mattingly. If reaching the playoffs isn’t enough, and winning a postseason series isn’t enough, and perhaps even reaching the NLCS isn’t enough, what exactly is being evaluated?
If Mattingly needs a World Series appearance simply to prevent Cora from replacing him, this doesn’t sound like an open managerial competition.
It sounds like a decision with an escape clause.
And then there is the part that makes the entire arrangement even more unusual.
The Phillies’ general manager is Mattingly’s son.
Preston Mattingly has held that position since November 2024. When his father replaced Thomson, the two became what is believed to be the first father-son general manager-manager combination in major-league history. The Phillies have structured the chain of command so both ultimately report to Dombrowski, which means Preston is not simply sitting upstairs determining whether his father keeps his job.
Still.
Think about the dynamic.
Preston Mattingly is helping run a baseball operation trying to reach October. His father is managing the team trying to get there. And now, in the middle of that pursuit, a national report says another manager is expected to take over unless Don Mattingly gets the Phillies all the way to the World Series.
There is no normal version of that.
It does not mean the clubhouse will unravel. Veteran players have spent their careers dealing with contract uncertainty, trade rumors, coaching changes and every other distraction a six-month season produces.
It does not mean Nightengale’s report came directly from the Phillies, either.
But it is fair to ask what anyone connected to the organization gains from having this conversation now.
Mattingly already carries the interim tag. Everyone knew Dombrowski could conduct a managerial search after the season. Cora’s name has hovered around the Phillies ever since Dombrowski acknowledged approaching him in April. The former Red Sox manager worked for Dombrowski when Boston won the 2018 World Series, making the connection obvious.
None of that needed another reminder on Aug. 16.
Not with Bryce Harper, Trea Turner, Kyle Schwarber and the rest of this roster trying to squeeze into October.
Not with every bullpen decision and lineup choice carrying increasing importance.
And certainly not when Mattingly has done almost everything the Phillies reasonably could have asked after inheriting a 9-19 team.
Maybe Cora ultimately is the better long-term choice. He has won a World Series. Dombrowski knows him. There are legitimate reasons Philadelphia could decide he is the manager it wants for the next phase of this roster.
That decision can be made after the season.
The Phillies have another problem first.
They have to get there.
For the next 37 games, Don Mattingly is responsible for navigating one of baseball’s most expensive rosters through a playoff race while knowing that even October might not be enough to keep his job.
His son is helping run the front office above him.
And somewhere outside the organization, Alex Cora’s name continues hovering over all of it.
The Phillies fought for four months to make September meaningful again.
Now they will enter it with perhaps the strangest managerial dynamic of any contender in baseball.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
