For 24 hours, the Phillies had to sit with the noise.
Five Cincinnati home runs. Eleven runs allowed. A pitching staff punished inside a ballpark that can make every elevated pitch feel dangerous.
By Thursday night, there was almost nothing left to hear.
Jesús Luzardo silenced the Reds for seven innings, Jonathan Bowlan handled the eighth and Jhoan Duran escaped the only genuine crisis of the night in the ninth as the Phillies closed their series in Cincinnati with a 1-0 victory at Great American Ball Park.
It was not a spectacular offensive response to Wednesday’s 11-5 loss. It was something more useful.
It was control.
The Phillies scored once, collected five hits and spent most of the night searching for a crack against Brady Singer. Luzardo made certain they could afford to wait. He allowed two hits, walked two and struck out 11, improving to 8-4 while lowering his ERA to 3.51. The left-hander also remained unbeaten away from Philadelphia, moving to 6-0 with a 1.38 ERA through 11 road starts.
That road dominance mattered Thursday because the Phillies supplied him with no margin.
Cincinnati’s first hit did not arrive until Tyler Stephenson singled with two outs in the second. Luzardo responded by retiring Noelvi Marte, then settled into the kind of rhythm that made every Reds plate appearance feel increasingly temporary.
The Phillies did little more against Singer.
Bryson Stott doubled with two outs in the second, but the opportunity ended there. Singer then retired 13 consecutive hitters, moving briskly through a lineup that could not square him up or force him into extended innings.
Through six, the game had become less a contest between two offenses than a refusal by either starting pitcher to blink.
Philadelphia finally created traffic in the seventh. Kyle Schwarber singled, but Bryce Harper immediately grounded into a double play. Brandon Marsh followed with another single, and Alec Bohm was hit by a pitch, giving the Phillies their first real opportunity to break the scoreless tie.
Stott flied out.
Another opening disappeared.
That made the eighth inning feel less like a rally than a narrow escape from a game that appeared destined to remain scoreless indefinitely.
Singer hit Gabriel Rincones Jr., and Derek Hill entered to run. J.T. Realmuto moved Hill into scoring position with a groundout. Justin Crawford then reached for a pitch and sent a ground ball through the right side, bringing Hill home with the only run either club would score.
It was not loud. It did not need to be.
The Phillies had spent most of the series dealing in extremes. Zack Wheeler struck out 14 in a 4-1 victory Tuesday. The Reds answered with five homers and 11 runs Wednesday. Thursday became something else entirely: a game decided by one clean swing, one well-timed run and a pitching staff unwilling to surrender it.
Bowlan retired all three batters he faced in the eighth.
Duran made the ninth more complicated.
JJ Bleday worked a long at-bat before singling, then stole second. Duran hit Spencer Steer, placing two runners aboard with nobody out and turning a 1-0 lead into a test of nerve.
The inning could have unraveled quickly. Instead, Duran overpowered Eugenio Suárez and Tyler Stephenson for consecutive strikeouts. Marte then grounded to third, and the Phillies walked off the field with Duran’s 23rd save in 24 opportunities.
The victory moved the Phillies to 52-42 and secured the series before their final road stop ahead of the All-Star break.
There was no offensive eruption Thursday. No barrage. No dramatic counterpunch to what Cincinnati had done the night before.
There was simply a better answer.
The Reds spent Wednesday filling the ballpark with home-run celebrations.
Luzardo and the Phillies spent Thursday taking every sound away.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
