![]() |
| Mike Schmidt hit 313 homers during the 1980s for the Phillies. | CREDIT: Getty Images |
Consider this for a moment: From 1980 through 1989, Mike Schmidt hit more home runs for the Philadelphia Phillies than Von Hayes, Juan Samuel, Glenn Wilson and Gary Matthews combined.
And he still had 19 homers to spare.
So, admittedly, there's not much suspense surrounding the top spot on our list. But what about everybody else? Was Hayes better than Philadelphia remembers? Was Samuel as productive as he was electrifying? And what are we supposed to make of Pete Rose?
That's where this gets interesting.
Today, the Philadelphia Baseball Review launches a new series exploring the greatest players and performances throughout Phillies history. We'll travel across generations, dig into the statistical archives, revisit some unforgettable personalities and perhaps challenge a few long-held beliefs about the franchise.
We begin in the 1980s, a decade that opened with a parade down Broad Street and closed with the most significant player in franchise history walking away from the game.
For this exercise, we're considering only regular-season production in a Phillies uniform between 1980 and 1989, with a minimum of 500 plate appearances. We're weighing longevity, sustained production, peak performance, baserunning and advanced hitting metrics, including weighted runs created plus (wRC+), which adjusts offensive production for ballpark and league conditions, with 100 representing league average.
This isn't a ranking of the decade's greatest all-around players. Defense isn't part of the equation.
Let the arguments begin.
10. Ozzie Virgil Jr. (1980–85)
.246/.319/.422 | 46 HR | 154 RBI | 106 wRC+
Before Darren Daulton became one of the most dangerous offensive catchers in baseball, there was Ozzie Virgil.
Over the 1984 and 1985 seasons, Virgil combined to hit 37 home runs and drive in 123 runs. He earned an All-Star selection in 1985 before the Phillies shipped him to Atlanta in a trade that brought Steve Bedrosian and Milt Thompson to Philadelphia.
Virgil's offensive profile would probably be better appreciated today than it was four decades ago. His batting average was relatively unimpressive, but his power and ability to draw walks made him a productive hitter.
Consider that Virgil hit just three fewer home runs than Glenn Wilson did for the Phillies during the decade, despite receiving nearly 1,000 fewer plate appearances.
There's some value hiding in that .246 batting average.
9. Jeff Stone (1983–87)
.291/.340/.395 | 241 H | 68 SB | 104 wRC+
For a few months in 1984, Philadelphia had reason to wonder whether it was witnessing the emergence of a superstar.
In 51 games that season, Stone collected 67 hits in 185 at-bats. He hit .362, reached base at a .394 clip and stole 27 bases.
Imagine a young Phillies outfielder arriving in the middle of a season today, hitting .362 and stealing a base approximately every other game. How much attention would that generate?
Stone never sustained that remarkable level of production, but his overall Phillies numbers remain respectable. He also succeeded on 80 percent of his stolen-base attempts with the club.
His career is one of the more intriguing what-ifs of the decade.
.291/.340/.395 | 241 H | 68 SB | 104 wRC+
For a few months in 1984, Philadelphia had reason to wonder whether it was witnessing the emergence of a superstar.
In 51 games that season, Stone collected 67 hits in 185 at-bats. He hit .362, reached base at a .394 clip and stole 27 bases.
Imagine a young Phillies outfielder arriving in the middle of a season today, hitting .362 and stealing a base approximately every other game. How much attention would that generate?
Stone never sustained that remarkable level of production, but his overall Phillies numbers remain respectable. He also succeeded on 80 percent of his stolen-base attempts with the club.
His career is one of the more intriguing what-ifs of the decade.
8. Joe Morgan (1983)
.230/.370/.403 | 16 HR | 59 RBI | 116 OPS+
Want to understand why modern baseball analysts spend so much time talking about on-base percentage? Take a look at Joe Morgan's 1983 season.
At 39, Morgan arrived in Philadelphia with two MVP awards, two World Series championships and a résumé that would eventually carry him to Cooperstown.
He hit just .230 for the Phillies.
But he also walked 89 times, homered 16 times and successfully stole 18 bases in 20 attempts.
Think about this: Morgan finished the season with just four more hits than walks.
His .370 on-base percentage was the product of a sophisticated understanding of the strike zone, a characteristic that defined his career long before advanced metrics entered baseball's mainstream vocabulary.
Morgan's Philadelphia tenure lasted only one season, but his contributions helped propel the Wheeze Kids to the National League pennant.
.230/.370/.403 | 16 HR | 59 RBI | 116 OPS+
Want to understand why modern baseball analysts spend so much time talking about on-base percentage? Take a look at Joe Morgan's 1983 season.
At 39, Morgan arrived in Philadelphia with two MVP awards, two World Series championships and a résumé that would eventually carry him to Cooperstown.
He hit just .230 for the Phillies.
But he also walked 89 times, homered 16 times and successfully stole 18 bases in 20 attempts.
Think about this: Morgan finished the season with just four more hits than walks.
His .370 on-base percentage was the product of a sophisticated understanding of the strike zone, a characteristic that defined his career long before advanced metrics entered baseball's mainstream vocabulary.
Morgan's Philadelphia tenure lasted only one season, but his contributions helped propel the Wheeze Kids to the National League pennant.
7. Ricky Jordan (1988–89)
.293/.319/.436 | 23 HR | 118 RBI | 112 wRC+
The Phillies of the late 1980s didn't give their fans many reasons to get excited. Then, on July 17, 1988, Ricky Jordan stepped into the batter's box at Veterans Stadium.
After drawing a walk in his first major league plate appearance, Jordan launched a three-run home run off Houston's Bob Knepper in his first official at-bat.
It was quite an introduction.
Jordan hit .308 with 11 homers and 43 RBIs in 69 games that summer. He followed that performance with 149 hits and 75 RBIs in 1989.
His aggressive approach limited his on-base production, but through his first two major league seasons, Jordan gave the Phillies a legitimate offensive threat.
Had the decade extended another season or two, his standing on this list might have changed considerably. But his first 213 major league games were impressive enough to earn him a spot.
.293/.319/.436 | 23 HR | 118 RBI | 112 wRC+
The Phillies of the late 1980s didn't give their fans many reasons to get excited. Then, on July 17, 1988, Ricky Jordan stepped into the batter's box at Veterans Stadium.
After drawing a walk in his first major league plate appearance, Jordan launched a three-run home run off Houston's Bob Knepper in his first official at-bat.
It was quite an introduction.
Jordan hit .308 with 11 homers and 43 RBIs in 69 games that summer. He followed that performance with 149 hits and 75 RBIs in 1989.
His aggressive approach limited his on-base production, but through his first two major league seasons, Jordan gave the Phillies a legitimate offensive threat.
Had the decade extended another season or two, his standing on this list might have changed considerably. But his first 213 major league games were impressive enough to earn him a spot.
6. Bake McBride (1980–81)
.298/.331/.434 | 231 H | 108 RBI | 112 wRC+
How often do we talk about Bake McBride when discussing the offensive firepower of the 1980 world champions?
Probably not enough.
That season, McBride hit .309 with 33 doubles, 10 triples, nine home runs and 87 RBIs.
He finished with more hits than Schmidt and more RBIs than every other player on the team except Schmidt.
McBride also struck out just 58 times in 593 plate appearances.
That combination of contact, gap power and productivity made him an important piece of the championship lineup. He didn't need to drive the ball over the fence to make opposing pitchers uncomfortable.
Injuries limited his contributions in 1981, and the Phillies traded him to Cleveland before the 1982 season.
His time in Philadelphia during the decade was brief, but the quality of his production was undeniable.
.298/.331/.434 | 231 H | 108 RBI | 112 wRC+
How often do we talk about Bake McBride when discussing the offensive firepower of the 1980 world champions?
Probably not enough.
That season, McBride hit .309 with 33 doubles, 10 triples, nine home runs and 87 RBIs.
He finished with more hits than Schmidt and more RBIs than every other player on the team except Schmidt.
McBride also struck out just 58 times in 593 plate appearances.
That combination of contact, gap power and productivity made him an important piece of the championship lineup. He didn't need to drive the ball over the fence to make opposing pitchers uncomfortable.
Injuries limited his contributions in 1981, and the Phillies traded him to Cleveland before the 1982 season.
His time in Philadelphia during the decade was brief, but the quality of his production was undeniable.
5. Lonnie Smith (1980–81)
.333/.399/.454 | 158 H | 54 SB | .853 OPS
Here's a name that might surprise you.
Across parts of two seasons at the beginning of the decade, Lonnie Smith reached base at nearly a .400 clip while hitting .333 and stealing 54 bases.
As a rookie in 1980, he hit .339 in 100 games and finished third in National League Rookie of the Year voting. He followed that performance by hitting .324 during the strike-shortened 1981 season.
Smith's speed and ability to reach base created constant problems for opposing teams.
The Phillies traded him following the 1981 season. In 1982, with St. Louis, he finished second in National League MVP voting and helped the Cardinals win a World Series.
In retrospect, the Phillies had a tremendous young offensive talent on their hands.
They just didn't have him for very long.
.333/.399/.454 | 158 H | 54 SB | .853 OPS
Here's a name that might surprise you.
Across parts of two seasons at the beginning of the decade, Lonnie Smith reached base at nearly a .400 clip while hitting .333 and stealing 54 bases.
As a rookie in 1980, he hit .339 in 100 games and finished third in National League Rookie of the Year voting. He followed that performance by hitting .324 during the strike-shortened 1981 season.
Smith's speed and ability to reach base created constant problems for opposing teams.
The Phillies traded him following the 1981 season. In 1982, with St. Louis, he finished second in National League MVP voting and helped the Cardinals win a World Series.
In retrospect, the Phillies had a tremendous young offensive talent on their hands.
They just didn't have him for very long.
4. Gary Matthews (1981–83)
.279/.363/.417 | 38 HR | 200 RBI | 121 wRC+
If there was a hitter who deserved a little more attention during the latter stages of the Phillies' championship era, it was the man they called Sarge.
In three seasons with Philadelphia, Matthews produced at a rate 21 percent better than league average, according to wRC+.
He drew 194 walks against 210 strikeouts, stole 49 bases and scored 217 runs.
Then there was October of 1983.
Facing the Dodgers in the National League Championship Series, Matthews hit .429 with three home runs in four games, earning series MVP honors.
The following spring, the Phillies traded Matthews to the Cubs, where he promptly led the National League with a .410 on-base percentage.
Matthews could hit for power, work a count and contribute on the bases. He was a more complete offensive player than his traditional counting statistics might suggest.
.279/.363/.417 | 38 HR | 200 RBI | 121 wRC+
If there was a hitter who deserved a little more attention during the latter stages of the Phillies' championship era, it was the man they called Sarge.
In three seasons with Philadelphia, Matthews produced at a rate 21 percent better than league average, according to wRC+.
He drew 194 walks against 210 strikeouts, stole 49 bases and scored 217 runs.
Then there was October of 1983.
Facing the Dodgers in the National League Championship Series, Matthews hit .429 with three home runs in four games, earning series MVP honors.
The following spring, the Phillies traded Matthews to the Cubs, where he promptly led the National League with a .410 on-base percentage.
Matthews could hit for power, work a count and contribute on the bases. He was a more complete offensive player than his traditional counting statistics might suggest.
3. Juan Samuel (1983–89)
.263/.310/.439 | 100 HR | 413 RBI | 249 SB | 103 wRC+
If this were a ranking of the most exciting Phillies of the 1980s, we might have a legitimate debate about the top spot.
Samuel was practically tailor-made for the artificial turf at Veterans Stadium.
In his first full major league season in 1984, he collected 191 hits, 36 doubles, 19 triples, 15 home runs and 72 stolen bases.
Three years later, he hit 28 homers, drove in 100 runs, scored 113 times and stole 35 bases.
In an interview conducted in 2008 and published by FanGraphs in 2012, Samuel explained his approach to the running game to baseball writer David Laurila.
“I tried to focus on stealing 50 or more bases every year,” Samuel said.
Consider the offensive variety in his Philadelphia career: 176 doubles, 71 triples, 100 homers and 249 stolen bases.
His tendency to strike out and reluctance to take walks prevented him from becoming a truly elite hitter. His 103 wRC+ reflects those shortcomings, though that metric does not capture the value of his baserunning.
But there was nobody else in Philadelphia during the decade who could manufacture offense quite like Samuel.
.263/.310/.439 | 100 HR | 413 RBI | 249 SB | 103 wRC+
If this were a ranking of the most exciting Phillies of the 1980s, we might have a legitimate debate about the top spot.
Samuel was practically tailor-made for the artificial turf at Veterans Stadium.
In his first full major league season in 1984, he collected 191 hits, 36 doubles, 19 triples, 15 home runs and 72 stolen bases.
Three years later, he hit 28 homers, drove in 100 runs, scored 113 times and stole 35 bases.
In an interview conducted in 2008 and published by FanGraphs in 2012, Samuel explained his approach to the running game to baseball writer David Laurila.
“I tried to focus on stealing 50 or more bases every year,” Samuel said.
Consider the offensive variety in his Philadelphia career: 176 doubles, 71 triples, 100 homers and 249 stolen bases.
His tendency to strike out and reluctance to take walks prevented him from becoming a truly elite hitter. His 103 wRC+ reflects those shortcomings, though that metric does not capture the value of his baserunning.
But there was nobody else in Philadelphia during the decade who could manufacture offense quite like Samuel.
2. Von Hayes (1983–89)
.278/.366/.440 | 107 HR | 474 RBI | 177 SB | 123 wRC+
It's probably time Philadelphia gave Von Hayes a little more credit.
More than four decades after the Phillies surrendered five players to acquire him from Cleveland, that trade continues to influence how his career is remembered.
But what happens when we forget the trade and simply examine his production?
Hayes collected 987 hits, 203 doubles, 107 home runs and 501 walks for the Phillies during the 1980s.
He also stole 177 bases.
In 1986, he led the National League with 46 doubles and 107 runs scored, hitting .305 and finishing eighth in MVP voting.
In 1989, he hit a career-high 26 home runs, walked 101 times and stole 28 bases.
Samuel understood the burden his teammate carried. In his interview with FanGraphs, he explained the expectations placed on any player acquired in such a deal.
If that player “doesn’t become Superman,” Samuel said, criticism is inevitable.
Hayes was never Superman. He was, however, an exceptionally versatile offensive player.
And there's a considerable statistical gap between him and Samuel as a hitter. Hayes posted a .366 on-base percentage during the decade, compared with Samuel's .310, while still contributing significant power and speed.
The advanced metrics make a persuasive case that Hayes was the second-best offensive player Philadelphia had throughout the decade.
.278/.366/.440 | 107 HR | 474 RBI | 177 SB | 123 wRC+
It's probably time Philadelphia gave Von Hayes a little more credit.
More than four decades after the Phillies surrendered five players to acquire him from Cleveland, that trade continues to influence how his career is remembered.
But what happens when we forget the trade and simply examine his production?
Hayes collected 987 hits, 203 doubles, 107 home runs and 501 walks for the Phillies during the 1980s.
He also stole 177 bases.
In 1986, he led the National League with 46 doubles and 107 runs scored, hitting .305 and finishing eighth in MVP voting.
In 1989, he hit a career-high 26 home runs, walked 101 times and stole 28 bases.
Samuel understood the burden his teammate carried. In his interview with FanGraphs, he explained the expectations placed on any player acquired in such a deal.
If that player “doesn’t become Superman,” Samuel said, criticism is inevitable.
Hayes was never Superman. He was, however, an exceptionally versatile offensive player.
And there's a considerable statistical gap between him and Samuel as a hitter. Hayes posted a .366 on-base percentage during the decade, compared with Samuel's .310, while still contributing significant power and speed.
The advanced metrics make a persuasive case that Hayes was the second-best offensive player Philadelphia had throughout the decade.
1. Mike Schmidt (1980–89)
.277/.385/.540 | 313 HR | 929 RBI | 151 wRC+
There are some remarkable numbers associated with Mike Schmidt's career.
But isolating his production during the 1980s provides an entirely different appreciation for his brilliance.
Consider: Schmidt hit more home runs than any player in Major League Baseball during the decade. He won three National League MVP awards. He recorded eight consecutive seasons with at least 30 home runs. He collected 818 walks and 566 extra-base hits. He hit 48 home runs in 1980 and another 31 in just 102 games in 1981.
His closest challenger on baseball's home run leaderboard for the decade was Atlanta's Dale Murphy, who hit 308.
Murphy, however, played 217 more games.
In its January 29, 1990, issue, The Sporting News named Schmidt its Player of the Decade. Baseball writer Bill Brown described him as “possibly the most complete” player of his generation.
Schmidt's dominance was such that a season featuring 33 home runs and 93 RBIs, as he produced in 1985, could almost feel disappointing.
How many players in Philadelphia sports history have established expectations like that?
The most impressive aspect of Schmidt's 151 wRC+ isn't simply the number itself. It's that the number represents an entire decade of offensive production, including the declining final stages of his career.
For ten years, his offensive production per plate appearance was 51 percent better than league average.
There was Mike Schmidt.
And then there was everybody else.
.277/.385/.540 | 313 HR | 929 RBI | 151 wRC+
There are some remarkable numbers associated with Mike Schmidt's career.
But isolating his production during the 1980s provides an entirely different appreciation for his brilliance.
Consider: Schmidt hit more home runs than any player in Major League Baseball during the decade. He won three National League MVP awards. He recorded eight consecutive seasons with at least 30 home runs. He collected 818 walks and 566 extra-base hits. He hit 48 home runs in 1980 and another 31 in just 102 games in 1981.
His closest challenger on baseball's home run leaderboard for the decade was Atlanta's Dale Murphy, who hit 308.
Murphy, however, played 217 more games.
In its January 29, 1990, issue, The Sporting News named Schmidt its Player of the Decade. Baseball writer Bill Brown described him as “possibly the most complete” player of his generation.
Schmidt's dominance was such that a season featuring 33 home runs and 93 RBIs, as he produced in 1985, could almost feel disappointing.
How many players in Philadelphia sports history have established expectations like that?
The most impressive aspect of Schmidt's 151 wRC+ isn't simply the number itself. It's that the number represents an entire decade of offensive production, including the declining final stages of his career.
For ten years, his offensive production per plate appearance was 51 percent better than league average.
There was Mike Schmidt.
And then there was everybody else.
What about Pete Rose?
Rose is perhaps the most notable omission from this list.
Between 1980 and 1983, he collected 618 hits, scored 300 runs and hit .279 for Philadelphia. He also led the National League with 140 hits in 1981.
But his offensive production declined considerably toward the end of his Phillies career, leaving him with a 95 wRC+ for the decade.
Other players worthy of consideration include Milt Thompson, Glenn Wilson, Manny Trillo, Greg Gross and Joe Lefebvre.
John Kruk, who hit .331 after arriving in Philadelphia in 1989, failed to meet our minimum plate appearance requirement.
Don't worry, though. We'll be seeing plenty of Kruk when we get to the 1990s.
That's part of the beauty of digging through baseball history. There are always more numbers to discover, more players to appreciate and more arguments to have.
And we're just getting started.
More Phillies Coverage
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
