 |
| Youth winter training has become a hot topic in baseball circles. | CREDIT: ATS Baseball |
By the time November arrives, the grass is empty, the bats are tucked away and, somewhere in the Philadelphia suburbs, an eight-year-old is being driven to another indoor baseball workout.
Somebody will call it development. But development toward what?
That question should shape every winter baseball decision a family makes. For an eight-year-old travel player, the offseason should hardly resemble baseball season. For a 13- or 14-year-old preparing for high school, purposeful training makes considerably more sense.
The mistake is assuming the same plan works for both.
“It really makes little sense to have a young, still-developing athlete focus on just one sport,” said Rocco Sanias, a Trevose youth baseball coach with a background in physical therapy.
Sanias sees more than a scheduling problem. He sees an approach that can place unnecessary stress on growing bodies.
“These kids who are throwing year-round are doing more harm than good to their shoulders, ligaments and everything else,” he said. “I see dads acting as if Tommy John surgery at the age of 12 is like a badge of honor or something. Truly, it’s sad.”
His larger point deserves attention.
“Kids need to become athletes. Play different sports. Work the entire body.”
At eight, that might mean basketball, swimming, soccer, playground games or simply running around with friends. A young player can still pick up a bat, practice a few swings or take ground balls when appropriate. The issue isn't baseball itself. It's the notion that progress demands a formal, year-round baseball calendar.
The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends young athletes have two to three months away from each sport annually and at least one day each week free of organized athletics.
For pitchers, Sanias believes the obsession with velocity is particularly troubling.
“Throwing for the radar gun is a surefire way to ruin things,” he said. “Focus instead on proper arm technique, arm care, location of pitches, and leave the breaking pitches alone until your arm can properly handle the technique, which usually isn't before middle school, if not later.”
It's an important distinction. A pitcher who can locate a fastball, repeat his delivery and understand how to compete has developed skills that don't necessarily register on a radar gun.
MLB and USA Baseball's Pitch Smart guidelines recommend at least four months off throwing annually for pitchers eight and younger, including two to three consecutive months. The same rest recommendation applies to 13- and 14-year-old pitchers.
Pitch Smart also advises against breaking pitches for the youngest players. For 13- and 14-year-olds, it recommends introducing them only after establishing consistent fastball and changeup skills.
That doesn't mean a player entering ninth grade should spend the winter on the couch.
The jump to high school baseball is substantial. The bases are farther apart. The game moves faster. Players may face opponents who are older, stronger and more polished. A freshman hopeful has legitimate reasons to improve strength, speed, mobility and baseball fundamentals before tryouts.
Tony Langston, a former Philadelphia Public League coach, believes modern players often bring impressive power, both at the plate and on the mound. But he questions whether certain broader athletic qualities have been lost.
“Kids were athletes,” Langston said of an earlier generation. “That isn't taking anything away from kids today, but when you get to the bigger field and playing high school and college, the expectations are that you will have range, some athleticism, cardio, and know how to present as an athlete over simply a baseball player.”
There's a difference between swinging hard in a cage and taking an extra base. Between throwing 80 mph and moving well enough to field your position. Between looking good in a workout video and making a play with the game on the line.
For an incoming freshman, two or three supervised strength and movement sessions weekly, combined with targeted hitting and defensive work, could provide an excellent winter foundation. Throwing should resume gradually after appropriate rest, not begin with a velocity contest.
And a winter basketball season? That may be an asset, not an obstacle, provided the overall workload remains reasonable.
Parents are often sold a different message: Fall behind now and never catch up. Another lesson. Another team workout. Another invoice.
But the long game should matter more than the next showcase, ranking or social-media clip.
At eight, a successful winter might end with a child eager for the first spring practice. At fourteen, it might end with a stronger, more capable athlete prepared for a high school opportunity.
Both outcomes count as development.
The point of winter training isn't to win winter.
It's to build a player who can still thrive when spring — and the years that follow — finally arrive.
More Phillies Coverage
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
