At the plate, Turner was spectacular. At shortstop, he endured one of his most difficult defensive performances of the season.
By the end, the production outweighed the problems.
Turner doubled, homered twice and drove in five runs as the Phillies opened an important homestand with a 10-7 victory over the Dodgers at Citizens Bank Park. His second home run marked the 200th of his career, while his first-inning double was the 300th of his career.
Those milestones framed a night that was anything but orderly.
Turner committed an official error in the first inning when he mishandled a ground ball from Mookie Betts. Three other balls later got past him on plays that offered at least a reasonable chance for an out. One contributed to the Dodgers’ sixth-inning rally, when Los Angeles reduced what had been a four-run deficit to one. Another came during a ninth inning that became much more uncomfortable than Philadelphia expected.
Each time the defensive mistakes threatened to become the story, Turner answered with his bat.
His two-out, two-run homer in the second completed a four-run Phillies inning and gave Cristopher Sánchez early room to work. Gabriel Rincones Jr. opened the scoring with an RBI double, Justin Crawford added a sacrifice fly and Turner supplied the inning’s biggest swing.
The Dodgers slowly chipped away.
Betts scored Los Angeles’ first run in the fourth. The Dodgers then pushed two more across in the sixth, forcing Sánchez from the game and pulling within 4-3. Turner’s inability to convert a bases-loaded ground ball helped extend the rally and placed Philadelphia in danger of losing control of a game it had led comfortably.
Turner responded almost immediately.
Brandon Marsh began the bottom of the sixth with a solo homer. Later in the inning, Turner drove a three-run shot off the left-field foul pole, restoring Philadelphia’s cushion and turning a one-run game into an 8-3 advantage.
It was Turner’s 200th career homer and the 20th multi-homer game of his career. More importantly for the Phillies, it came at the exact moment the Dodgers had begun to make the game feel unstable.
That was the defining tension of Turner’s night.
He was responsible for much of Philadelphia’s separation, yet his defense repeatedly gave Los Angeles additional opportunities. He created five runs with his bat while making Sánchez and the bullpen work harder behind him.
Sánchez still completed 5⅓ innings, allowing three runs on seven hits with seven strikeouts and no walks. The left-hander improved to 12-4 after navigating traffic early and pitching through several extended innings.
The Phillies continued adding power after Turner’s second homer.
Bryce Harper hit his 200th home run as a Phillie in the seventh inning, becoming the ninth player in franchise history to reach that mark. Derek Hill followed with a solo shot in the eighth. Philadelphia finished with five home runs from four players.
Even then, the Dodgers refused to disappear.
Betts completed a four-hit, two-homer performance with a two-run shot during a three-run ninth. Another ball escaped Turner during the inning, and Jhoan Duran was eventually summoned to record the final out after the Phillies had carried a six-run lead into the frame.
The ending prevented the victory from feeling routine. It also provided an appropriate conclusion to Turner’s unusual performance.
There was no clean way to evaluate his night.
The defensive lapses were costly and could have been devastating in a closer game. Against a Dodgers lineup capable of turning extra opportunities into crooked numbers, the Phillies cannot afford that kind of inconsistency at shortstop.
But Turner’s offense was also the primary reason those mistakes did not determine the outcome.
He reached three career milestones, produced three extra-base hits and delivered the decisive swing after Los Angeles had pulled within a run. On a night when his defense repeatedly complicated matters, Turner’s bat kept rescuing the Phillies—and himself.
The Phillies did not receive a flawless performance from their shortstop.
They received something considerably more chaotic: five runs driven in, several runs placed in danger and, ultimately, enough offense to survive it all.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
