There are All-Star Games that belong to cities. There are All-Star Games that belong to players. And then there was the night in 1996 when Mike Piazza made Veterans Stadium feel like it belonged to both.
The box score says the National League beat the American League, 6-0, on July 9, 1996. It says Piazza went 2-for-3 with a home run, a double and two RBIs. It says he was named the game’s Most Valuable Player.
All of that is true.
It also barely explains the night.
Because for Piazza, that All-Star Game was never merely another showcase appearance for the best-hitting catcher in baseball. It was a regional homecoming, staged in the ballpark where he had once sat as a Phillies fan, watched Mike Schmidt from behind third base and imagined a future in the major leagues.
Born in Norristown and a graduate of Phoenixville Area High School, Piazza grew up immersed in Philadelphia sports. He served as a batboy when the Dodgers came to Veterans Stadium, admired Schmidt from the stands and dreamed of playing on the same field. By the summer of 1996, the 62nd-round draft pick had become baseball’s premier offensive catcher, the National League’s leading vote-getter for the All-Star Game and one of the sport’s biggest stars.
Then the All-Star Game came to Philadelphia.
That is where the night moved from impressive to unforgettable.
Before first pitch, five Phillies Hall of Famers — Mike Schmidt, Robin Roberts, Richie Ashburn, Steve Carlton and Jim Bunning — simultaneously threw ceremonial first pitches. Piazza caught Schmidt’s throw.
Years later, Piazza admitted that was the moment the emotions finally caught up to him.
“I’m running out of words to describe all this,” Piazza told reporters afterward. “It really hit me when I caught Mike Schmidt’s first pitch.”
He went on to explain that he had grown up watching Schmidt from the seats behind third base at Veterans Stadium. Schmidt had written a message on the ceremonial baseball wishing him the best. To then hit a home run and leave with the MVP trophy, Piazza said, was “just indescribable.”
Then he made sure nobody forgot it.
Leading off the bottom of the second inning against Cleveland’s Charles Nagy, Piazza turned on a fastball and launched it deep into the left-field upper deck. The blast, estimated at 445 feet, gave the National League a 2-0 lead and sent the Veterans Stadium crowd into a roar reserved for hometown heroes.
One inning later, Piazza struck again.
With runners on base, he ripped a line drive into the right-center-field gap for an RBI double, extending the National League lead to 4-0. It made him just the ninth player in All-Star Game history to homer and double in the same game.
Behind John Smoltz, Kevin Brown, Tom Glavine, Ricky Bottalico and a dominant National League pitching staff, the American League never recovered. The NL completed a 6-0 shutout in the only All-Star Game in history in which neither team issued a walk.
Yet the statistics tell only part of the story.
Piazza later called the performance “a small tribute to my dad.”
His father, Vince, had believed in him long before baseball did, throwing endless batting-practice sessions, encouraging him through years of doubt and leaning on family friend Tommy Lasorda to give his son an opportunity in professional baseball. On that July night in Philadelphia, Vince watched his son become the game's brightest star only a short drive from where the dream first began.
The symbolism reached beyond one spectacular performance.
Philadelphia has always viewed baseball as something passed down. Parents pass it to children. Heroes inspire future heroes. Ballparks become classrooms. Piazza represented every kid who had walked through the turnstiles at Veterans Stadium carrying a glove and believing impossible things.
That is why the 1996 All-Star Game still resonates.
Not because Piazza wore a Phillies uniform. He never did.
Not because Veterans Stadium was the sport’s grandest cathedral. It wasn’t.
It endures because one of the region’s own returned home at the height of his powers, caught a ceremonial first pitch from his childhood idol, then authored the signature performance of the evening.
Three decades later, with the All-Star Game returning to Philadelphia, that night remains one of the defining moments in the city’s All-Star history.
For one summer evening, the hometown stage belonged to Mike Piazza.
And he performed exactly the way every kid in those seats once imagined they would.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
