ORLANDO, Fla. -- The first day of the Winter Meetings didn’t bring the seismic Phillies headline everyone here is waiting for. Not the Kyle Schwarber headline. Not the J.T. Realmuto headline. Not even the Ranger Suárez headline that has quietly become one of the most intriguing subplots of the week.
And yet, somehow, Monday still felt like it was vibrating beneath everyone’s feet.
Because every executive, every agent, and every person in a lobby holding two cell phones and a paper cup of Starbucks keeps saying the same thing:
Something is coming. And the Phillies are sitting in the center of it.
The only ripple in the Schwarber universe came via The Athletic, which reported that the Pirates — yes, the Pirates — made an offer north of $100 million. Read that sentence again just to feel how strange it is to type.
But beyond that? No leaks. No “momentum.” No whispers about pen-to-paper.
Still, the industry believes the clock is ticking. MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand reported that multiple executives think Schwarber could sign before everyone checks out of their Disney hotel rooms. And if that happens, he’ll become the first big domino to fall — the one half the league is waiting on before executing the rest of their winter plans.
Around baseball, a Phillies reunion is still seen as not only plausible but logical. The Mets, Red Sox, Reds, and Pirates haven’t gone away. But the Phillies haven’t either. And that alone keeps this storyline squarely in the “any minute now” category.
The other half of the Phillies’ offseason stalemate didn’t move much either. But it did wiggle.
According to The Athletic’s Jen McCaffrey, the Red Sox have expressed interest in J.T. Realmuto. And while catching isn’t exactly at the top of Boston’s wish list, the rest of Realmuto’s profile is. A veteran right-handed bat. A pulled-line-drive hitter whose power plays toward the Monster. A defensive anchor who could instantly become the steadying force behind a very young pitching staff.
The Sox already like their internal options, but if they believe they’re closer to contending than their record suggested, Realmuto becomes a fascinating piece to monitor.
Maybe the quietest storyline of the day was about the pitcher who never makes noise. But the interest in Ranger Suárez is very real.
The Astros, Orioles, and Cubs have all been mentioned recently — three teams shopping in the “we want a playoff-tested arm without paying Yamamoto prices” aisle.
But then there are the Mets.
Not loudly. Not aggressively. But just enough to make rival officials raise an eyebrow.
Suárez fits everything they’re looking for: durability, elite strike-throwing, postseason experience, and the ability to make a rotation feel deeper than it actually is. If they strike out on the premium names, he’s exactly the kind of pitcher they could pivot to — a stabilizer who bridges their present with the wave of young arms they believe is coming.
And while no one is predicting a Philadelphia-New York bidding war, the possibility hangs there in the background like a cloud you’re not sure is stormy or just passing through.
The only real news Monday came from the Phillies themselves — and it didn’t involve a free agent.
Asked about the team’s bench-coach search, Dave Dombrowski told reporters, including Lochlahn March of the Philadelphia Inquirer, that the club is focused on hiring Don Mattingly.
“It’s not official, but we have really focused on speaking with Don and trying to make that happen, and we’re hopeful that it will,” Dombrowski said.
That’s not nothing. Mattingly spent the past three years as Toronto’s bench coach, but he also spent seven seasons inside this division as Miami’s manager. And there’s something undeniably poetic about the Phillies trying to land a bench coach whose son is sitting in the GM’s chair.
Preston Mattingly reinforced the club’s interest in bringing Schwarber back but acknowledged what everyone already assumed: if Schwarber does leave, Plan B becomes outfield depth. Which is a polite way of saying the Phillies’ current outfield group — Brandon Marsh, Otto Kemp, Johan Rojas, and Justin Crawford — is very much unfinished.
The expected trade of Nick Castellanos, sources say, remains a scenario everyone involved would welcome.
If Day One was the stage being set, Day Two is when the actors walk out and everyone starts checking their phones more aggressively.
Executives still believe Schwarber could move first. And when he does, it will unlock the rest of the market — for outfielders, for power bats, for clubs waiting to spend but unwilling to set the price.
Suárez remains the stealth storyline. Realmuto remains the quiet one that could become loud overnight.
And the Phillies? They’re doing what they’ve done all winter: keeping the room guessing, keeping the options open, and positioning themselves to strike a big-ticket item.
For a day that didn’t produce a headline, the Phillies somehow managed to remain the most interesting team in the room.
That’s the thing about the Winter Meetings.
The quiet days are usually the loudest.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of youth baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »