ORLANDO -- The offer that shifted the winter came from a team few expected.
According to multiple national reports, the Pittsburgh Pirates have made a formal push for free-agent slugger Kyle Schwarber, presenting a four-year proposal believed to exceed $100 million.
For a franchise that has rarely ventured into the upper tier of free-agent spending, the figure is striking. Pittsburgh’s largest previous free-agent contract remains Francisco Liriano’s three-year, $39 million deal, and their only nine-figure commitment of any kind is Bryan Reynolds’ eight-year, $106.75 million extension.
Yet here the Pirates are, reportedly opening the bidding on the most powerful left-handed bat on the market.
In one swoop, they didn’t just declare themselves contenders for Schwarber. They established the market floor. And while it’s refreshing to see the Pirates jump into the pool with such an offer, the reality remains that the financial heavyweights of the sport — clubs with deeper pockets, larger revenue streams, and far more flexibility — can, and likely will, dwarf Pittsburgh’s bid if they truly want Schwarber.
Whether the Pirates ultimately sign him or not, they have forced the Phillies into a decision that goes far beyond sentimentality or clubhouse value.
Schwarber reaches free agency at 32, but he does so after a season that breaks most conventional aging models for designated hitters.
In 2025, he played all 162 games for Philadelphia and hit .240/.365/.563 with 56 home runs and 132 RBIs. He led the National League in homers and led all of Major League Baseball in RBIs, while posting an OPS among the sport’s best and delivering a season-long performance that left him second in NL MVP voting behind Shohei Ohtani.
Across four seasons in Philadelphia, Schwarber has delivered elite power, patience, and October experience — traits that continue to define his value. Public projections and league evaluations have consistently placed him in the upper-20s to $30 million per season range on a four- or five-year contract.
Those expectations existed long before Pittsburgh’s interest became public. Now, with a concrete nine-figure offer in the mix, Schwarber’s market has an unmistakable shape.
The Pirates may have set the floor, but they are not alone in chasing him.
The New York Mets have been prominently mentioned as a suitor, with their financial strength and middle-of-the-order uncertainty creating a natural fit. The Mets don’t need to bluff, if they want Schwarber, they can simply outbid.
The Red Sox, Reds, and Orioles have also surfaced in national reporting as teams with interest or logical roster fits. Boston’s flexibility, Cincinnati’s payroll space, and Baltimore’s inexpensive young core all make Schwarber an attractive target.
None of those teams shares his history with Philadelphia. But free agency rarely prioritizes sentiment over structure, opportunity, and competitive window.
With a four-year, nine-figure offer already on the table elsewhere — and with several clubs capable of blowing past it — the Phillies now must decide how far they're willing to go.
So, where do the Phillies stand?
Across baseball circles, there has been a consistent belief that the Phillies’ top offseason priority is re-signing Schwarber. The interest is mutual. Schwarber has spoken repeatedly about his connection to the organization, and club officials view him as both a lineup engine and a cultural pillar.
But reporting leading into the Winter Meetings has suggested the sides are not particularly close to a deal.
Complicating matters is the broader roster puzzle. J.T. Realmuto is also a prominent free agent, and committing to both Schwarber and Realmuto at market value would limit the Phillies’ ability to pursue another marquee addition this offseason. That would push the club toward shorter-term signings and trade-driven solutions elsewhere on the roster.
Timing could be critical. Several national writers have floated the possibility that Schwarber may decide his future before the Winter Meetings conclude. If true, Philadelphia won’t have the luxury of a drawn-out negotiation.
If they want Schwarber back, they will need to match the seriousness of the market around him.
The Pirates’ bid ensures one thing: any offer that comes in significantly below nine figures or shorter than four years is no longer viable. Based on reporting and the way front offices typically value elite DH power, the realistic landscape now looks something like this: a baseline of four years and more than $100 million, reflecting Pittsburgh’s reported offer; a projected landing range of four to five years with an annual value in the upper-20s to around $30 million, depending on incentives and option structure; and, in a more aggressive bidding scenario, a five-year deal that pushes into the mid-$130 million range. Anything beyond that would require a club to accept notable long-term risk on a bat-first player, but it cannot be ruled out given the number of suitors and the scarcity of Schwarber’s skill set.
What is clear is that the Pirates’ number is no longer the ceiling — it is the entry point.
The Phillies cannot count on Schwarber choosing comfort over compensation. Not in this market. Not with the landscape reshaped the way it has been. If Schwarber’s camp intends to decide in Orlando, the Phillies cannot wait for the market to settle. Their strongest offer must arrive quickly enough to be weighed against higher-dollar alternatives.
This winter began with a simple question: Can the Phillies afford to keep Kyle Schwarber?
After Pittsburgh’s surprising foray into nine-figure territory, and with big-market clubs fully capable of surpassing that offer, the question now feels sharper:
Are the Phillies willing to pay full market value for the hitter who anchors their offense and has become one of the defining voices of their clubhouse?
The Pirates have set the floor.
Wealthier clubs may soon raise the ceiling.
And the next move belongs to Philadelphia.
Yet here the Pirates are, reportedly opening the bidding on the most powerful left-handed bat on the market.
In one swoop, they didn’t just declare themselves contenders for Schwarber. They established the market floor. And while it’s refreshing to see the Pirates jump into the pool with such an offer, the reality remains that the financial heavyweights of the sport — clubs with deeper pockets, larger revenue streams, and far more flexibility — can, and likely will, dwarf Pittsburgh’s bid if they truly want Schwarber.
Whether the Pirates ultimately sign him or not, they have forced the Phillies into a decision that goes far beyond sentimentality or clubhouse value.
Schwarber reaches free agency at 32, but he does so after a season that breaks most conventional aging models for designated hitters.
In 2025, he played all 162 games for Philadelphia and hit .240/.365/.563 with 56 home runs and 132 RBIs. He led the National League in homers and led all of Major League Baseball in RBIs, while posting an OPS among the sport’s best and delivering a season-long performance that left him second in NL MVP voting behind Shohei Ohtani.
Across four seasons in Philadelphia, Schwarber has delivered elite power, patience, and October experience — traits that continue to define his value. Public projections and league evaluations have consistently placed him in the upper-20s to $30 million per season range on a four- or five-year contract.
Those expectations existed long before Pittsburgh’s interest became public. Now, with a concrete nine-figure offer in the mix, Schwarber’s market has an unmistakable shape.
The Pirates may have set the floor, but they are not alone in chasing him.
The New York Mets have been prominently mentioned as a suitor, with their financial strength and middle-of-the-order uncertainty creating a natural fit. The Mets don’t need to bluff, if they want Schwarber, they can simply outbid.
The Red Sox, Reds, and Orioles have also surfaced in national reporting as teams with interest or logical roster fits. Boston’s flexibility, Cincinnati’s payroll space, and Baltimore’s inexpensive young core all make Schwarber an attractive target.
None of those teams shares his history with Philadelphia. But free agency rarely prioritizes sentiment over structure, opportunity, and competitive window.
With a four-year, nine-figure offer already on the table elsewhere — and with several clubs capable of blowing past it — the Phillies now must decide how far they're willing to go.
So, where do the Phillies stand?
Across baseball circles, there has been a consistent belief that the Phillies’ top offseason priority is re-signing Schwarber. The interest is mutual. Schwarber has spoken repeatedly about his connection to the organization, and club officials view him as both a lineup engine and a cultural pillar.
But reporting leading into the Winter Meetings has suggested the sides are not particularly close to a deal.
Complicating matters is the broader roster puzzle. J.T. Realmuto is also a prominent free agent, and committing to both Schwarber and Realmuto at market value would limit the Phillies’ ability to pursue another marquee addition this offseason. That would push the club toward shorter-term signings and trade-driven solutions elsewhere on the roster.
Timing could be critical. Several national writers have floated the possibility that Schwarber may decide his future before the Winter Meetings conclude. If true, Philadelphia won’t have the luxury of a drawn-out negotiation.
If they want Schwarber back, they will need to match the seriousness of the market around him.
The Pirates’ bid ensures one thing: any offer that comes in significantly below nine figures or shorter than four years is no longer viable. Based on reporting and the way front offices typically value elite DH power, the realistic landscape now looks something like this: a baseline of four years and more than $100 million, reflecting Pittsburgh’s reported offer; a projected landing range of four to five years with an annual value in the upper-20s to around $30 million, depending on incentives and option structure; and, in a more aggressive bidding scenario, a five-year deal that pushes into the mid-$130 million range. Anything beyond that would require a club to accept notable long-term risk on a bat-first player, but it cannot be ruled out given the number of suitors and the scarcity of Schwarber’s skill set.
What is clear is that the Pirates’ number is no longer the ceiling — it is the entry point.
The Phillies cannot count on Schwarber choosing comfort over compensation. Not in this market. Not with the landscape reshaped the way it has been. If Schwarber’s camp intends to decide in Orlando, the Phillies cannot wait for the market to settle. Their strongest offer must arrive quickly enough to be weighed against higher-dollar alternatives.
This winter began with a simple question: Can the Phillies afford to keep Kyle Schwarber?
After Pittsburgh’s surprising foray into nine-figure territory, and with big-market clubs fully capable of surpassing that offer, the question now feels sharper:
Are the Phillies willing to pay full market value for the hitter who anchors their offense and has become one of the defining voices of their clubhouse?
The Pirates have set the floor.
Wealthier clubs may soon raise the ceiling.
And the next move belongs to Philadelphia.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of youth baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »