Not after another October that began with fireworks and ended in disbelief — the kind of heartbreak that feels almost scripted in Philadelphia.
Orion Kerkering didn’t just throw a ball away in the 11th inning Thursday night. He threw an era into question.
That’s the cruel symmetry of this sport. You chase a dream long enough and it starts to look like destiny — until, suddenly, it doesn’t. And now the Phillies are left staring at a truth they can’t spin: this version of the team, this core, this clubhouse — they’ve reached the end of the line.
For four seasons, they’ve been everything this city demands — loud, flawed, fearless, and unforgettable. Ninety-six wins this year, a second straight division title, and months that once felt like destiny. But eras don’t last forever, and it’s clear this one has reached its expiration date.
You could tell just by hearing from the players in the clubhouse after Game 4 — especially from Kyle Schwarber.
This loss wasn’t just the end of a postseason series — it felt like the end of a run with this core. The silence said as much as the words.
“It felt like our group, even though we were down two games, we’ve shown that we’ve been able to overcome a lot of different things,” Schwarber said. “Deep down in my heart, I thought this was the team that was going to do it and overcome that.”
Schwarber was noticeably upset.
“They become family,” he said. “These guys all know how I feel about them. I’ve got a lot of respect for the guys in here, in our organization, the coaches — everyone top to bottom. This is a premier organization. And a lot of people should feel very lucky that you’re playing for a team that is trying to win every single year, and you have a fan base that cares and ownership that cares and coaches that care. You have everyone in the room that cares. We’re all about winning, and it’s a great thing. That’s why it hurts as much as any other year.”
And maybe that’s part of what hurts most.
Trea Turner, Bryce Harper, and Schwarber — the stars who define this era — went a combined 3-for-35 in the three games the Phillies lost in this series.
What comes next will hurt. It always does. This isn’t a video-game reset. It’s real life. It’s business. And it’s baseball in Philadelphia, where emotion collides with expectation and nobody gets out unscathed.
John Middleton isn’t built to sit quietly through another collapse. The owner feels every bruise his fan base takes, and that matters. He’ll want change — not cosmetic, but seismic.
Everything is on the table at this point. Manager Rob Thomson may not be back. Schwarber may not be back. J.T. Realmuto may not be back. Ranger Suárez may not be back.
Six players already have the Phillies’ payroll for 2026 north of $150 million. The farm system has questions, and the answers won’t come easy. Throw in the potential for a work stoppage following the 2026 season because of labor issues, and you have an offseason ahead full of intrigue and difficult decisions.
Even Thomson, usually calm and unshakable, looked beaten down. His voice quivered as he searched for words following Game 4. He didn’t have answers — just that faraway look of a man who knows what endings sound like.
Dave Dombrowski has work to do, and this time it probably won’t be as surgical as it will be massive. It has to be.
The window that once looked endless has closed, and what’s left isn’t just disappointment — it’s a reckoning. The Phillies can’t run it back anymore. They have to rebuild what’s next.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of youth baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »