The Phillies on Monday made it official: righthander David Robertson — yes, that David Robertson — is returning for a third stint in red pinstripes. The 16-year veteran inked a one-year deal and has been optioned to triple-A Lehigh Valley. It’s not the flashiest move on the transaction wire, but it might be one of the most quietly important.
Because even at 40, David Robertson still misses bats like it’s 2012.
Last season with Texas? A 3.00 ERA across 72 innings. Ninety-nine strikeouts. A strikeout rate (33.4%) that ranked sixth among all American League relievers. And according to Statcast? That placed him in the 96th percentile among all pitchers.
He did it with precision, experience, and mostly… a cutter. A nasty, vintage, bat-breaking cutter that he threw 63.4% of the time. Opponents hit just .163 against it and slugged a laughable .209. That wasn’t just effective — that was elite. Quietly, Robertson’s cutter might’ve been one of the single most dominant pitches in the league.
And the fastball? Still there. Averaged 93.3 mph — his best since Statcast began tracking in 2015 and a match for his 2023 peak.
You don’t post 1.9 fWAR as a reliever — ninth-best in the majors — at 39 years old by accident.
And now, Robertson is back in a familiar uniform. Again.
This marks his third go-round with the Phillies. The first? A high-profile signing in 2019 that turned sour after injury. The second? A trade deadline boost in 2022 that helped stabilize a playoff-bound bullpen. He pitched in eight postseason games that year — seven of them scoreless — and locked down Game 1 of the World Series in Houston.
He’s no stranger to October.
In fact, Robertson ranks ninth all-time in postseason appearances by a reliever (42) and owns a 3.04 ERA in the playoffs. He’s averaged 10.84 strikeouts per nine innings in his postseason career — tied with Walker Buehler for 13th-best among pitchers with at least 40 playoff innings.
But here’s the kicker: the Phillies didn’t give up anything to bring him back. No prospects. No assets moved. Just a veteran arm with elite metrics and postseason experience, now quietly stashed in Allentown.
That means they still have the capital, both financially and prospect-wise, to go bigger. To chase a lockdown closer if they want to. To hunt for a right-handed bat that can lengthen the lineup and protect Bryce Harper.
And that bat search? It may have just become more urgent.
Alec Bohm is expected to miss the next few weeks with a fractured left rib — a blow to a team that’s relied heavily on his presence near the heart of the order. The Phillies have already been aggressively pursuing bullpen help, but don’t be surprised if the front office shifts focus toward offensive reinforcements as the deadline approaches.
So maybe this is depth. Maybe it’s insurance.
It’s a low-risk move with minimal cost and zero impact on the club’s long-term plans.
But it could also be the kind of under-the-radar addition that helps steal a crucial win in September — the kind of win that shifts a pennant race, sharpens a postseason run, and reinforces a front office fully committed to a win-now window.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »