The Phillies improved Monday. The more uncomfortable question is whether they improved enough.
Dave Dombrowski added one of baseball’s most accomplished contact hitters in Luis Arraez, strengthened the bullpen with left-hander Brooks Raley and right-hander Caleb Kilian and acquired outfield depth in Kameron Misner. The deadline addressed two areas that had become impossible to ignore: a lineup that struggled to create traffic and a bullpen that needed additional late-inning options.
But the National League did not stand still.
The Phillies entered Monday tied with Arizona at 59-53, occupying one of the final two wild-card positions. Chicago owned the first wild card with a four-game cushion, while San Diego trailed Philadelphia by one game and Miami remained 1½ games back. The Phillies were also eight games behind Atlanta in the NL East, making the wild-card race their most realistic path unless the Braves experience a significant collapse.
Chicago treated the deadline like a team preparing to survive a postseason series.
The Cubs acquired Kevin Gausman, Braxton Garrett, Clay Holmes and Ryan Zeferjahn, giving them several different ways to assemble their rotation and bullpen during the final two months. They also added outfielder Tyrone Taylor. Chicago surrendered meaningful prospect capital, but it took a strong offensive club and built substantially more pitching depth around it.
That matters for the Phillies because Chicago was already four games ahead of them and entered Monday with a plus-89 run differential. Philadelphia’s differential was minus-four. The standings say they are separated by four games. Their overall performances suggest the distance has been larger.
Arraez unquestionably changes the Phillies’ offensive profile. He arrived leading the National League with a .324 batting average, an especially valuable skill for a club carrying a .304 on-base percentage that ranked second-lowest in the majors. Kyle Schwarber has supplied power and Bryce Harper has driven in runs, but too many Phillies innings have started and ended without anyone reaching base. Arraez provides a hitter capable of creating opportunities without relying on home runs.
The complication is everything Philadelphia must rearrange to accommodate him.
With Arraez expected to remain at second base, Bryson Stott could move to third, Alec Bohm could shift to first and Harper could return to right field. The Phillies are not simply inserting Arraez into an open position. They are potentially moving three established players and asking Harper’s surgically repaired throwing arm to handle the demands of the outfield again.
That does not automatically make the acquisition an offensive-defensive wash. Arraez has played improved defense at second this season after his glove contributed to a muted free-agent market. The risk comes from the collective disruption surrounding him, not necessarily from Arraez himself.
Dombrowski made another consequential bet by what he did not do.
The Phillies entered the deadline searching for stability at the back of the rotation. They had not won a game started by anyone occupying the fifth spot since May 18, and Andrew Painter had already been optioned to Triple-A after posting a 7.06 ERA over his first 65 major-league innings.
Yet while Chicago added multiple pitchers, San Diego acquired Robbie Ray and Los Angeles landed Tarik Skubal, the Phillies did not add a starting pitcher.
That decision amounts to a significant vote of confidence in Painter.
Painter has shown encouraging signs since returning, but the Phillies are now relying on the 23-year-old to stabilize a rotation spot that has been a problem for more than two months. Dombrowski could have acquired a veteran to protect Painter, reduce his workload or provide an alternative if his command issues return. Instead, he used his available prospect capital on Arraez and bullpen help.
It is a bet on Painter’s talent, development and recent progress. It is also a gamble that separates the Phillies’ deadline from several of their direct competitors.
Philadelphia does not necessarily need Painter to start a postseason game. Zack Wheeler, Cristopher Sánchez and Jesús Luzardo give the Phillies a formidable three-man October rotation. They need Painter to help get them there without forcing the bullpen to cover four or five innings every fifth day.
Atlanta, meanwhile, became deeper without rearranging its everyday lineup. The Braves added outfielder Lane Thomas, starters Bailey Falter and Tyler Mahle and left-handed reliever Brent Suter. None was the biggest name moved Monday, but Atlanta addressed its outfield, rotation and bullpen while reinforcing a roster that already entered the day 22 games above .500.
Then there are the Dodgers, who acquired Skubal and somehow made baseball’s most intimidating roster more imposing. Los Angeles also added Kris Bubic and Seth Halvorsen, providing additional pitching options around a club that entered Monday with a plus-150 run differential.
San Diego remained aggressive, acquiring Ray, who brought a 3.08 ERA through 122⅔ innings. The Padres entered Monday only one game behind the Phillies and had won eight of nine.
The Phillies are better than they were Sunday. Arraez gives the offense a dimension it lacked, while Raley and Kilian deepen a bullpen that needed reinforcements.
But Chicago stockpiled pitching. Atlanta reinforced an already superior roster. Los Angeles added an ace. San Diego acquired another proven starter.
Philadelphia improved its chances of reaching the postseason. Whether it can keep pace may depend on two interconnected bets: that Arraez’s offense will outweigh the defensive disruption around him, and that Painter is finally ready to become the starter the Phillies have been waiting for.
Loading the latest Phillies coverage...
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
