There was a time when Nick Castellanos’ name was written in ink on the Phillies’ lineup card, the kind of hitter who never had to wonder when — or if — he’d get an at-bat. Friday night in Phoenix was the opposite. He wasn’t even in the starting nine. He didn’t step on the field until the sixth inning. And then, in a role he still doesn’t entirely recognize as his own, he delivered one of the Phillies’ biggest swings of the month.
A pinch-hit. A two-run homer. No. 250 for his career. The kind of milestone that normally comes in the rhythm of everyday at-bats, not off the bench in the desert heat.
But that’s the strange reality of Castellanos 2.0. He’s 33, signed to a $100 million contract, and living in a crowded outfield that now includes Harrison Bader, Brandon Marsh, Max Kepler and Weston Wilson. His at-bats aren’t guaranteed. His role isn’t defined. Yet in the Phillies’ 8–2 win over the Diamondbacks, he looked like a man determined to make sure his swings still matter.
It had been more than a month — Aug. 17, to be exact — since he last hit a ball over the wall. But in the eighth inning, with the Phillies clinging to a two-run lead, he turned on a fastball and watched it soar into the left-field seats. Suddenly, it was 5–2, and suddenly, it felt like Castellanos had forced his way back into the October conversation. He even added an RBI single in the ninth, padding both the lead and his résumé.
Think about this: it was the first time in his career that Castellanos had come off the bench and driven in multiple runs in a game. A man who has spent his entire professional life as a lineup fixture just authored a career first as a part-timer.
The season’s numbers tell the story of why he’s here. He’s hitting .255 with 17 homers and 69 RBIs. Since July 1, though, he’s slumped to a .213 average, seven homers, and a .606 OPS. But September has carried a different vibe — a .323 average, a .901 OPS in 10 games. Maybe, just maybe, this is the adjustment kicking in.
Even Castellanos admits he doesn’t love the setup. The communication with Rob Thomson, he said, hasn’t always been seamless. And Thomson himself acknowledged the difficulty: “For a guy that’s played every day since he’s come to the big leagues … to take on this role is difficult.” But Friday night offered a glimpse that he can still impact a pennant race in a part-time capacity.
The Phillies have already clinched the NL East. They’ve won 31 of 46 since the trade deadline. October is guaranteed. What isn’t guaranteed is how Castellanos fits into the postseason puzzle. Starter? Bench bat? Multi-inning reliever roles exist for pitchers. Maybe Castellanos is becoming the hitter’s version of that: a weapon in waiting.
And that’s the twist in all of this. The man who once thrived on rhythm and routine is now finding ways to thrive on the chaos of unpredictability. His 250th career homer was less about the round number than the new reality: if the Phillies get this version of Castellanos for the next month, they’ll have yet another way to win a baseball game when the lights get brighter.
His future in Philly? That can be debated after October.
Loading Phillies schedule...
Loading NL East standings...
Support the Mission. Fuel the Movement.
You’re not just funding journalism — you’re backing the future of youth baseball in Philly.
👉 Join us on Patreon »