Taijuan Walker can’t make another start for the Phillies this season.
After a string of disappointing performances, it’s clear that continuing to rely on him would jeopardize the team’s postseason aspirations. Walker’s recent outings have been disastrous, and Wednesday’s 10-0 loss to the Houston Astros was the final straw.
Walker gave up six runs on a season-high 13 hits, including a home run, over six innings. Despite his best efforts, he couldn’t avoid further damage to his ERA, which now stands at an alarming 6.50—the worst among starters with at least 14 appearances this season. His inability to generate strikeouts or miss bats is evident, as he managed just two swinging strikes on 93 pitches. The last time a Phillies pitcher allowed 13 hits without a strikeout was in 1948, highlighting just how dire the situation has become.
The impact of Walker’s decline extends beyond his personal stat line. The Phillies, once tied for the best record in baseball, have now lost two of their last six games—both started by Walker. These losses have put undue strain on the bullpen and drained the team’s momentum.
Manager Rob Thomson, acknowledging the seriousness of the situation, admitted, “We have to talk about that.” The realization is growing that keeping Walker in the rotation is no longer a viable option.
Walker’s struggles have triggered a broader conversation about his future with the team. Signed for another two years and owed roughly $39 million, the Phillies face a daunting decision. While eating such a significant sum is unprecedented in Phillies history, it has been done by other teams. Walker’s once-promising tenure now faces the possibility of a drastic resolution.
The Phillies must decide quickly as they prepare for a crucial series against the Braves. They might explore alternatives like rookie Tyler Phillips or a waiver add to provide rotation depth. However, neither option is guaranteed to offer the stability needed at this critical juncture.
Walker’s attempts to increase his velocity and improve his split-finger fastball have yet to yield results. While Thomson has praised Walker’s effort and resilience, he also acknowledged that accolades alone don’t translate into victories.
The Phillies’ postseason hopes could hinge on finding a more reliable arm.
As September unfolds and the Phillies gear up for October, they must confront the reality of Walker’s decline. In a season where every decision could shape their playoff trajectory, moving on from Taijuan Walker may be the necessary step to regain momentum and keep their championship dreams alive.
