Monday, November 26, 2012

How Upton compares to other free agents via Wins Above Replacement; how that may impact an offer from the Phillies

PBR - Wins Above Replacement, affectionately known as WAR, is a statistical metric that measures  a player’s total contributions to their team in one simple number.
Think of WAR as the number you would look at if a key player were injured and a replacement player, either from the minors or the bench, were inserted into their place - it answers the question of how much value (wins)  a team would be losing.  
I won't bore you with the mathematical formula but you can easily find WAR on FanGraphs (fWAR) and Baseball-Reference (rWAR). The metric is league and park neutral, so you can compare WAR figures across years, leagues, and parks.
With the news surrounding free agent B.J. Upton, I went ahead and put together a simple chart including the WAR figures for several free agent outfielders - the chart includes WAR from last season along with a three-year average '(10-'12.)
Now that we see the WAR for each of these players, how can we decipher their value on the free agent market?
Sky Andrecheck attempted to answer this question with a post a few years back on Rich Lederer's Baseball Analysts Web site - WAR, Salary, and Service: Estimating Dollars Per Win. Andrecheck - and came up with the following equation using figures from 2008 to determine salaries for free agents: 5.53 + (WAR*1.23).
To come up with a balanced number I went ahead and found two salaries for each player - one based on '12 WAR and another on the three-year average - I then averaged the two salaries together and came up with the following figures (salaries in the millions, per season):
By no means is this method perfect. It is a given that Josh Hamilton will receive more than $12 million a year, but the other salaries at least seem plausible if all things are considered equal. Upton made $7 million in 2012, but now he's looking at $13 to $15 million. Shane Victorino made $9.5 million and he's also looking for something in the vicinity of $13 million. 
If nothing else we can at least compare the WAR figures to the salaries from Andrecheck's formula and determine the comparative value of the five free agent outfielders included in the chart.
Think of it this way, if both Upton and Victorino are going to give the Phillies the same amount of wins over an average player, than isn't Victorino  a better option if he can be bought at a significantly cheaper price?
- Patrick Gordon is the editor of the Philadelphia Baseball Review. Contact him at or @Philabaseball on Twitter.